Vision 2008; 14:1929-1939
Received 13 August 2008 | Accepted 21 October 2008 | Published 28 October 2008
1Department of Ophthalmology, Columbia University, New York, New York; 2Department of Ophthalmology, the Second Affiliated Hospital of China Medical University, Shenyang, China
Correspondence to: Takayuki Nagasaki, Department of Ophthalmology, Columbia University, 630 West 168th Street, New York, NY, 10032; Phone: (212) 305-4654; FAX: (212) 305-7153; email: firstname.lastname@example.org; Dr. Zhang is currently with the Department of Internal Medicine, Yale University, New Haven, CT.
Purpose: Dstncorn1 mice lack normal destrin expression and develop corneal abnormality shortly after birth such as epithelial hyperplasia and total vascularization. Thus, the mice serve as a model for ocular surface disorders. To determine the nature of epithelial defects, we examined whether epithelial homeostasis is altered in these corneas.
Methods: Dstncorn1 mice were crossed with ubiquitous GFP mice to generate a double homozygous line, GFP-Dstncorn1, and cell movements were determined by whole-mount histology and in vivo time-lapse microscopy, tracking the change of epithelial GFP patterns. Rates of cell division and the presence of label-retaining cells (LRCs) were determined by systemic bromodeoxyuridine (BrdU). Epithelial expression of keratins 8, 12, and 15, and MUC5AC were determined by whole-mount immunofluorescence.
Results: Epithelial cells in an adult GFP-Dstncorn1 cornea were generally immobile with no sign of directed movement for the entire life of the animal. These cells were not senescent because more than 70% of basal epithelial cells incorporated BrdU over a 24 h period. LRCs were widely distributed throughout a GFP-Dstncorn1 cornea. The epithelium of a GFP-Dstncorn1 cornea contained a mixed population of cells with a corneal and a conjunctival phenotype as judged by the expression of keratins and MUC5AC.
Conclusions: Epithelial cells of an adult GFP-Dstncorn1 cornea are generally stationary, mitotically active, and contain LRCs, indicating that the epithelium is self-sustained, which in turn suggests that epithelial stem cells are present within the cornea. Epithelial homeostasis of adult GFP-Dstncorn1 corneas is abnormal, mimicking that of a normal conjunctiva or a pathological, conjunctivalized cornea.
Dstncorn1 mice are a spontaneous mutant line that exhibit ocular surface abnormalities shortly after birth, including epithelial hyperplasia and stromal vascularization . The molecular defect has been identified as deficiency of destrin , an actin binding protein also known as actin depolymerizing factor (ADF). It is a member of the actin severing proteins that share sequence and functional similarity with cofilins . In addition to the naturally occurring Dstncorn1 mice, destrin-knockout mice generated by gene targeting also exhibited mild corneal hyperplasia . The requirement of destrin seems to be unique to the cornea because Dstncorn1 mice are fertile and appear normal, apart from the corneal defect. However, it is not known how a destrin mutation leads to phenotypic changes in a Dstncorn1 cornea.
Histology of Dstncorn1 corneas showed that the hyperplastic epithelium expressed an increased level of keratin 14 and involucrin while the level of keratin 12 was not altered . It has been shown that hemangiogenesis and lymphangiogenesis in the Dstncorn1 cornea depend on vascular endothelial growth factor receptor 3 (VEGFR3) signaling , but its relationship with a destrin mutation is not known. Recently it was suggested that vascularization of Dstncorn1 corneas arises from lack of soluble VEGF receptor, sflt-1, which was proposed as an essential factor for maintenance of avascularity in a normal cornea . In this scenario, the loss of destrin would be the initial event that leads to the loss of sflt-1 in a Dstncorn1 cornea, but this causal relationship has not been established at a molecular level.
Two of the major defects in a Dstncorn1 cornea, vascularization and abnormal epithelium, may arise independently of each other as a consequence of destrin deficiency. Alternatively, there may be a causal relationship between the two, i.e., either one may be a prerequisite for the other. Gross and histological observations suggested that a corneal surface irregularity occurred about a week before signs of neovascularization , favoring an idea that epithelial defects may trigger neovascularization. However, initial molecular events leading to vascularization may have been undetectable using histological techniques, and therefore, other possibilities remain viable at this time.
In this study, we focused on dynamic aspects of epithelial defects in a Dstncorn1 cornea by studying its epithelial homeostasis in the hope that this knowledge will eventually help the molecular elucidation of corneal defects due to destrin mutations. Our results suggest that epithelial homeostasis of a Dstncorn1 cornea is abnormal and similar to that of a normal conjunctival epithelium or a pathological epithelium of a conjunctivalized cornea, both of which feature an underlying stromal vasculature.
The animal studies adhered to the Association for Research in Vision and Ophthalmology Statement for the Use of Animals in Ophthalmic and Vision Research and was approved by the institutional animal care and use committee. Dstncorn1 (Stock Number 001649) and CAG-EGFP (Stock Number 003115) mice were obtained from the Jackson Laboratory (Bar Harbor, ME), crossed, and bred to generate a strain with homozygosity to both traits, which we refer to as GFP-Dstncorn1 in this paper.
For histology, the eyes were isolated after sacrificing the animal with intraperitoneal pentobarbital (100 mg/kg). Whole-mounts containing an entire area of ocular surface were prepared as described previously  and stained with DAPI to reveal nuclei. Fluorescence patterns of DAPI and GFP were visualized with a fluorescence microscope with appropriate filter sets (Axioskop2, Carl Zeiss, Oberkochen, Germany). Overlapping microscopic images were acquired digitally (Orca 100; Hamamatsu, Hamamatsu City, Japan and Metamorph; Molecular Dynamics., Downingtown, PA), and assembled with Photoshop (Adobe Systems, San Jose, CA) to prepare a large image file of the entire ocular surface for analysis.
Immunohistochemistry was performed with cornea whole mounts that were fixed with 1% paraformaldehyde in PBS for 30 min. For BrdU staining, corneal whole-mounts were pre-treated for epitope retrieval with 2 N HCl for 15 min at 37 °C. Dstncorn1 corneas were further processed by incubation with 0.2 mg/ml pepsin (Sigma-Aldrich, St. Louis, MO) in 0.1 N HCl for 5 min at 37 °C so that antibody penetration to basal layers was satisfactory. For double immunofluorescence staining, corneal GFP fluorescence was quenched completely by treatment with methanol before antibody incubation. Rat anti-BrdU antibody was from Serotec (Raleigh, NC). Rabbit anti-destrin antibody (GV-13) was purchased from Sigma-Aldrich. Rat anti-K8 antibody (Troma-I) was obtained from Developmental Studies Hybridoma Bank (University of Iowa, Iowa City, IA). Goat anti-K12 (L15) and goat anti-MUC5AC (K20) were from Santa Cruz Biotechnology (Santa Cruz, CA). Mouse anti-K15 was from Lab Vision (Fremont, CA) and rabbit anti-K15 was from ProteinTech (Chicago, IL). Secondary antibodies conjugated with either Texas-red, Cy2, or Cy3 were purchased from Jackson Immunoresearch Laboratories (West Grove, PA). All immunostaining reactions without primary antibodies were negative under the same image acquisition conditions for staining with primary antibodies. This ensured that fluorescent signals were due to specific reactions of primary antibodies to target tissues.
In vivo microscopy and digital imaging were performed as described previously [8,9] using an M2Bio fluorescence microscope system (Kramer Scientific, Valley Cottage, NY), which is based on an SV11 stereo microscope (Carl Zeiss). Mice were anesthetized with a stream of 3% isoflurane in oxygen. The eye was lightly proptosed with a thin vinyl-coated, U-shaped flexible metal wire for microscopy. GFP fluorescence images were obtained with a 1.6X objective with a zoom at 1.0X using a digital camera (Coolsnap ES; Photometrics, Tucson, AZ) controlled by MetaVue (Molecular Devices, Downingtown, PA). Image resolution was approximately 4.0 µm/pixel under these conditions. At each time point, at least seven images were taken, three at the central cornea at different focal planes, and one each at the superior, the inferior, the temporal, and the nasal portion of the peripheral cornea. This was facilitated by a set of custom-made gimbals, which accommodated a mouse platform and could be rotated freely to bring an ocular surface area of interest to the apex to face the objective. GFP patterns were recorded at intervals of one to four weeks, and movement of GFP positive cells was analyzed from time lapse sequences as before [8,10].
To determine cell division rates, DNA was metabolically labeled with bromodeoxyuridine (BrdU; Sigma-Aldrich) for 24 h in live mice of 13-20 weeks. BrdU (0.6 mg/day) was given systemically with an Alzet osmotic pump (model 1003D; DURECT Corp., Cupertino, CA) that was implanted subcutaneously in the back. The animal was sacrificed 24 h later to determine DNA synthesis during the 24 h period. Whole mounts were prepared to determine BrdU-incorporating cells by immunohistochemistry (see above). BrdU-labeling rates over 24 h were determined as a ratio of the number of BrdU positive cells and the number of DAPI-stained cells in an area of 170×210 µm in digitized microscopic images. At least six such areas were selected randomly in each of the five eyes for GFP-Dstncorn1 corneas and three eyes for CAG-EGFP corneas.
For determination of label-retaining cells (LRCs), four adult mice (18-24 weeks old) were labeled with BrdU with a subcutaneous Alzet pump (model 2002) for two consecutive weeks. The Alzet pump was removed at the end of the two-week labeling, and the mouse was sacrificed eight weeks later to harvest both eyes when only slow cycling cells would retain BrdU in their nuclei. After whole mount BrdU immunofluorescence, individual BrdU retaining cells (i.e., LRCs) were located under a fluorescence microscope and plotted manually on a print-out of a whole mount outline. Manual determination of BrdU positive cells under the microscope was aided by focusing up and down and switching between BrdU and DAPI channels to ensure only epithelial BrdU signals were counted.
To observe homeostatic movement of epithelial cells, we crossed CAG-EGFP mice with Dstncorn1 mice to generate a line, GFP-Dstncorn1, which was homozygous to both traits. Double homozygosity was confirmed by the respective phenotype. For Dstncorn1 phenotype, spontaneous corneal vascularization (Figure 1A) and epithelial hyperplasia (Figure 1B) were observed as with Dstncorn1 homozygous mice . For GFP phenotype, fluorescence intensity of the corneal epithelial GFP indicated homozygosity [10,11]. We examined more than 100 GFP-Dstncorn1 mice, which all exhibited spontaneous corneal vascularization and epithelial hyperplasia without exception. Destrin, which is lacking in Dstncorn1 mice , was absent in GFP-Dstncorn1 corneas while it was uniformly positive in CAG-EGFP corneas as judged by destrin whole mount immunofluorescence (data not shown). These results indicated that a GFP-Dstncorn1 cornea was functionally equivalent to a Dstncorn1 cornea. Accordingly, all of the following experiments were performed with GFP-Dstncorn1 mice.
To study epithelial homeostasis in a GFP-Dstncorn1 cornea, we first analyzed homeostatic, natural movements of epithelial cells by histology and in vivo time lapse microscopy. In normal CAG-EGFP mice (Figure 2, right panel), corneal GFP patterns were mosaic in two-week-old animals (a three-week cornea is shown in Figure 2) while radial stripes emerged at the limbus at three to four weeks and continued to move centripetally and reached the center by 10 weeks . GFP-Dstncorn1 corneas (Figure 2, left panel) also exhibited mosaic patterns after birth, but radial stripes appeared as early as two weeks at the peripheral cornea. The centripetal progression of budding radial stripes stopped at four to six weeks and never reached the center of the cornea. Instead, GFP patterns became diffuse and globular without a sign of extended stripes, radial or otherwise, indicating that there was neither centripetal movement nor sustained directional movement of epithelial cells in an adult GFP-Dstncorn1 cornea.
To confirm this, cell movement was determined directly by in vivo time lapse fluorescence microscopy, tracking epithelial GFP patterns in 20 eyes with an average follow-up time of 39 weeks including four eyes over 52 weeks. Two of the representative sequences are shown in Figure 3. In the sequence of Figure 3A, epithelial GFP exhibited a mixture of diffuse and stripe patterns, suggesting that the direction of cell movements had not been established yet. At six weeks, radial stripes became the dominant pattern, indicating that there were general cell movements in a radial direction. By 10 weeks, however, GFP stripes turned into irregularly shaped patches, suggesting that the radial cell movements had stopped before 10 weeks. Thereafter, GFP patterns were diffuse and remained generally immobile while their size appeared to grow slowly in all directions (Figure 3A,C,D), which is perhaps reflecting gradual and random local cell movements, accompanied by clonal growth of GFP positive cells. A time lapse sequence in Figure 3B shows images up to 79 weeks and demonstrates that epithelial GFP remained generally stationary for the life of the animal as the natural life span of Dstncorn1 and GFP-Dstncorn1 mice is about 70-80 weeks (unpublished observations). This profile was in clear contrast to a normal cornea that exhibited constant centripetal movement of epithelial cells from the limbus to the corneal center .
Another parameter of epithelial homeostasis, cell division, was determined by two methods. In the first, we determined the rate of DNA synthesis during a 24 h period by labeling the animals with BrdU for 24 h straight using an osmotic pump implanted subcutaneously (Figure 4). Quantitation of the labeled cells indicated that more than 70% of basal epithelial cells in a GFP-Dstncorn1 cornea incorporated BrdU during this period compared with 46% in a normal CAG-EGFP cornea (Table 1).
In the second method, we determined the distribution of label-retaining cells (LRCs) by a BrdU pulse chase, which was a two-week pulse label with BrdU with an osmotic pump and an eight-week chase during which nuclear BrdU was halved at each cell division. This protocol identified LRCs, which are regarded as a population of cells containing epithelial stem cells [12-14]. It has been well documented that normal corneas are devoid of such LRCs [13,15,16], and we confirmed this under our labeling protocol (Figure 5A). On the other hand, experiments with eight GFP-Dstncorn1 corneas all showed that LRCs were widely distributed in the cornea (Figure 5C). Many of the BrdU positive nuclei were somewhat smaller and exhibited an irregular shape (Figure 5D) compared with oval-shaped limbal LRC nuclei of a CAG-EGFP eye (Figure 5B). In general, there were more LRCs in the peripheral cornea, mostly in the basal layer, than in the central portion where LRCs were mostly in layers just above the basal layer. Regardless of the distribution patterns, LRCs were clearly present in the cornea of GFP-Dstncorn1 mice.
Results of cell migration and cell division indicated that epithelial cells of GFP-Dstncorn1 cornea are not of the corneal phenotype. To determine whether GFP-Dstncorn1 epithelial cells are of the conjunctival phenotype, we first examined keratin expression in GFP-Dstncorn1 corneas using K12 as a corneal marker  and K15 as a conjunctival marker  (Figure 6). The epithelial surface of the GFP-Dstncorn1 cornea was diverse, and no two corneas showed the same pattern of keratin expression. Nevertheless, there was a tendency that K12 positive cells were distributed in the central portion of the cornea while K15 positive cells were in the peripheral region in contact with the limbus. K12 and K15 patterns were nearly exclusive to each other in many parts of the cornea (Figure 6), although there were occasional cells that were positive with both or neither. Efforts to establish a correlation between histological changes and change of cell movements were not successful because histological patterns varied considerably among individual GFP-Dstncorn1 corneas in the same age groups.
We also looked at expression of K8 that is normally found in the conjunctiva [19,20] and the expression of a goblet cell marker, MUC5AC , neither of which was found in a normal cornea even at advanced ages (K8 in Figure 7B, MUC5AC in Figure 7D). K8 positive cells were present in all the GFP-Dstncorn1 corneas we examined (Figure 7). They were scattered throughout the cornea with various patterns and formed a cluster of several cells but never a larger group. This K8 pattern was found as early as three weeks of age and appeared similar at all ages studied (Figures 7A,C,E). On the other hand, MUC5AC appeared to be absent in the cornea of GFP-Dstncorn1 mice younger than 25 weeks (data not shown). However, a considerable number of MUC5AC positive cells were present in all five corneas that we examined at 51 weeks or older (51-73 weeks; Figure 7F). Double staining for K8 and MUC5AC revealed that nearly all MUC5AC positive cells were K8 positive (Figure 7E,F for low power; Figure 7H,I for high power).
Our results demonstrate that epithelial cells of a GFP-Dstncorn1 mouse cornea are different from those of a normal cornea and that they are distinguished by the following unique characteristics; 1) they are generally immobile, 2) they exhibit higher rates of cell division, 3) some of them are LRCs, and 4) they show a mixture of corneal (K12) and conjunctival (K15, K8, and MUC5AC) phenotypes. These observations make it clear that epithelial homeostasis is abnormal in a GFP-Dstncorn1 cornea.
One of the implications of our findings is that the epithelium of a GFP-Dstncorn1 cornea may contain epithelial stem cells within it. This is suggested by the observation that epithelial cells were generally stationary during the life of the animal and yet mitotically active, indicating that the GFP-Dstncorn1 epithelium is a self-sustained tissue, which would contain its own stem cells. This notion was supported by the finding that LRCs were present in the epithelium of a GFP-Dstncorn1 cornea. Although all LRCs are clearly not stem cells , some LRCs are likely to be stem cells [12,13]. The situation is similar to the skin where cells are generally immobile in a lateral direction and maintained by keratinocyte stem cells within the skin . This is, however, unlike a normal corneal epithelium, which is maintained by a constant influx of epithelial cells that are generated by limbal stem cells [23-25].
A comparison of epithelial homeostasis suggests that the epithelium of a GFP-Dstncorn1 cornea resembles that of a conjunctiva or a conjunctivalized cornea. This point is based on our characterization of the normal conjunctival epithelium  and the epithelium of a conjunctivalized cornea (unpublished data), both of which are self-sufficient in cell renewal and appear to contain uniformly distributed stem cells. However, one marked difference is that a Dstncorn1 cornea exhibits several patches of epithelial hyperplasia throughout the cornea while such hyperplastic zones do not usually exist in a conjunctival epithelium or a conjunctivalized cornea. One parameter that we have not measured is a rate of cell desquamation, which may also be a contributing factor in the hyperplastic phenotype.
An adult GFP-Dstncorn1 cornea contained a mixed population of cells expressing markers for corneal and conjunctival epithelium. MUC5AC-positive goblet cells were also present in older mice. Non-corneal cells may have migrated from the conjunctiva, but we failed to detect directed epithelial cell movements in a GFP-Dstncorn1 cornea including those from the conjunctiva into the cornea for the entire life in some animals. Therefore, it is likely that those cells of a conjunctival phenotype in the cornea arose by differentiation of epithelial stem cells in situ rather than immigration of conjunctival cells into the cornea. This in turn suggests that a GFP-Dstncorn1 cornea contains 1) three types of stem cells, each specific for corneal epithelial cells, conjunctival epithelial cells, or goblet cells; 2) multi-potent stem cells that are capable of differentiating into all three types of cells (and perhaps others); or 3) a combination of both. Further investigation may shed light on the nature of tissue-specific stem cells and their differentiation.
As to differentiation cues, variable patterns of K12 and K15 in GFP-Dstncorn1 corneas of the same age groups suggest that there is a stochastic element to the epithelial differentiation, i.e., some epithelial cells go through abnormal differentiation (manifested by expression of odd keratins), but it is not possible a priori to predict which cells do and where in the cornea they appear. The stochasticity may be a feature of epithelial differentiation in a normal cornea that continues well into adulthood because it has been reported that K12 expression in the mouse cornea did not stabilize until the mouse was six months old .
Our results with GFP-Dstncorn1 mice demonstrate that destrin-defective epithelial cells lost the ability to move centripetally at a constant rate in the cornea. Given the involvement of cofilin/destrin in cell movement in a variety of tissues [3,27], it is likely that loss of destrin is directly related to the loss of epithelial cell movement in a GFP-Dstncorn1 cornea. On the other hand, it is not clear whether the loss of destrin is the primary cause of other epithelial abnormalities such as increased division rates and hyperplasia. At this time, it is equally possible that such abnormalities are cumulative results of secondary events such as lack of cell movement triggered by destrin loss. Further investigations are required to determine how destrin deficiency leads to a variety of epithelial abnormalities at a molecular level.
Having established the abnormal cell movement in a Dstncorn1 cornea in this study, we note an apparent correlation between epithelial cell movement and underlying stromal vascularization. On one hand, epithelial cells exhibit constant centripetal movement in a normal avascular cornea . On the other hand, epithelial cells are generally stationary in a vascularized cornea including a Dstncorn1 cornea (this study), a pathological conjunctivalized cornea , and a normal conjunctiva . Similarly, epithelial cell movements were reportedly disturbed in a vascularized Pax6+/− mouse cornea [29,30]. These observations raise an intriguing possibility that constant homeostatic epithelial cell movement may be a required component of avascularity in a normal cornea and that lack of such movement may trigger vascularization. Many variations of this scheme are possible including those that incorporate a vital role of sflt-1  or VEGFR3 , but further discussion should await more experimental results. Dstncorn1 mice should serve as a valuable tool for this purpose, especially in combination with Dstncorn1–2J , an independent destrin mutant mouse line with no corneal vascularization.
This study was supported by grants from National Institute of Health (EY015835) and Research to Prevent Blindness. Troma-I (anti-K8 antibody) was obtained from the Developmental Studies Hybridoma Bank developed under the auspices of the NICHD and maintained by University of Iowa.