Received 21 June 2010 | Accepted 25 September 2010 | Published 30 September 2010
1Unité Cibles pour le Diagnostic et la Thérapie, Centre de Biotechnologie de Sfax, Tunisie; 2mRNA Metabolism in Normal and Pathological Cells, CGMC, CNRS, Université Lyon 1, Villeurbanne, France; 3Service d’Ophtalmologie, C.H.U.H. Bourguiba de Sfax, Tunisie; 4Service d'O.R.L., C.H.U. H. Bourguiba de Sfax, Tunisie
Correspondence to: Dr. Saber Masmoudi, Unité Cibles pour le Diagnostic et la Thérapie, Centre de Biotechnologie de Sfax, Tunisie; Phone: 0021674871816 ; FAX: 0021674875818; email: email@example.com.
Purpose: Recessive mutations of the myosin VIIA (MYO7A) gene are reported to be responsible for both a deaf–blindness syndrome (Usher type 1B [USH1B] and atypical Usher syndrome) and nonsyndromic hearing loss (HL; Deafness, Neurosensory, Autosomal Recessive 2 [DFNB2]). The existence of DFNB2 is controversial, and often there is no relationship between the type and location of the MYO7A mutations corresponding to the USH1B and DFNB2 phenotype. We investigated the molecular determinant of a mild form of retinopathy in association with a subtle splicing modulation of MYO7A mRNA.
Methods: Affected members underwent detailed audiologic and ocular characterization. DNA samples from family members were genotyped with polymorphic microsatellite markers. Sequencing of MYO7A was performed. Endogenous lymphoid RNA analysis and a splicing minigene assay were used to study the effect of the c.1935G>A mutation.
Results: Funduscopy showed mild retinitis pigmentosa in adults with HL. Microsatellite analysis showed linkage to markers in the region on chromosome 11q13.5. Sequencing of MYO7A revealed a mutation in the last nucleotide of exon 16 (c.1935G>A), which corresponds to a substitution of a methionine to an isoleucine residue at amino acid 645 of the myosin VIIA. However, structural prediction of the molecular model of myosin VIIA shows that this amino acid replacement induces only minor structural changes in the immediate environment of the mutation and thus does not alter the overall native structure. We found that, although predominantly included in mature mRNA, exon 16 is in fact alternatively spliced in control cells and that the mutation at the very last position is associated with a switch toward a predominant exclusion of that exon. This observation was further supported using a splicing minigene transfection assay; the c.1935G>A mutation was found to trigger a partial impairment of the adjacent donor splice site, suggesting that the unique change at the last position of the exon is responsible for the enhanced exon exclusion in this family.
Conclusions: This study shows how an exonic mutation that weakens the 5′ splice site enhances a minor alternative splicing without abolishing a complete exclusion of the exon and therefore causes a less severe retinitis pigmentosa than the USH1B-associated alleles. It would be interesting to examine a possible correlation between intrafamilial phenotypic variability and the subtle variation in exon 16 inclusion, probably related to genetic background specificities.
Myosin VIIA, an unconventional myosin, is a member of a large superfamily of actin-associated molecular motors. It is composed of a structurally conserved head, neck, and tail regions. The latter binds actin and hydrolyzes ATP to produce force and movement. Myosin VIIA physiologic function is best studied in the sensory hair cells of the inner ear and the retina. In the inner ear, myosin VIIA is required for hair bundle morphogenesis and mechanotransduction [1,2]. Within the retina, myosin VIIA localizes to the cilium of the photoreceptors, to the apical region of retinal pigment epithelium (RPE) cells, and to melanosome within RPE cells [3-5]. In accordance with its expression pattern in retina, myosin VIIA regulates opsin and melanosome transports and the phagocytosis of shed outer segments by RPEs [6,7]. Myosin VIIA has been implicated in recessively inherited Usher syndrome type 1B (USH1B) , atypical Usher syndrome (USH3) , nonsyndromic recessive (Deafness, Neurosensory, Autosomal Recessive 2 [DFNB2]) , and dominant (DFNA11)  hearing loss (HL). USH1B is clinically characterized by prelingual severe to profound HL, prepubertal progressive retinitis pigmentosa (RP), and vestibular areflexia. A progressive HL, variable vestibular problems, and RP are characteristic of USH3. Although the existence of myosin VIIA (MYO7A) recessive mutations that are associated with nonsyndromic HL phenotype is still controversial, there is evidence of variability in the clinical onset and diagnosis of RP among patients with MYO7A mutations. In the large Tunisian family used to define the DFNB2 locus, funduscopy revealed mild RP in five out of 25 affected persons with HL . In the Pakistani DFNB2 family, one deaf patient (41 years old) had slightly subnormal rod and cone responses and a suboptimal quality electroretinogram (ERG).
Over 130 mutations in MYO7A have been identified and are listed in the Human Gene Mutation Database, most leading to a diagnosis of USH1B. Mutations in MYO7A were reported in five families with nonsyndromic recessive HL. It was hypothesized that DFNB2 mutations cause a less severe phenotype than the USH1B-associated alleles because the resulting protein retains some degree of normal function, at least in retina. This hypothesis was confirmed only in the DFNB2 Pakistani family. Riazuddin et al.  showed that green fluorescent protein (GFP)-tagged form of myosin VIIa containing deletion p.E1716del localizes properly to stereocilia in transfected mouse inner ear hair cells, similarly to the wild-type protein, which argues for the residual functional activity of the altered protein.
Using genetic linkage and sequencing analyses, we identified a missense mutation (c.1935G>A) in a Tunisian family segregating nonsyndromic HL. Funduscopy showed that RP is mild in adult patients. The mutation is located at the last nucleotide of MYO7A exon 16. The altered mRNA displayed a predominant exclusion of exon 16. A functional analysis using splicing minigene transfection assay further supported the effect of the mutation on exon exclusion.
Two deaf individuals from a Tunisian family were enrolled through a deaf school. During a home visit, we ascertained additional four deaf individuals (Figure 1). Informed consent was obtained from patients and control individuals in accordance with the ethics committee of the University Hospital of Sfax. Pure tone audiometry was performed. Affected members underwent evaluation for balance using caloric testing and ophthalmological investigation, including fundus ophthalmoscopy. Clinical history and physical examinations of family members ruled out the implication of environmental factors in the etiology of HL and RP. Ten ml of blood samples have been taken from the vein in the antecubital fossa from ten family members. Immediately, tubes were inverted about 5 times and labeled with the subject identification code. Samples were refrigerated to 4 °C for no more than 4 h. Genomic DNA was extracted from whole blood following a standard phenol-chloroform method. Briefly, lymphocytes were incubated in a solution of Sodium dodecyl sulfate detergent and proteinase K. The DNA solution is first extracted with a phenol/chloroform/isoamyl alcohol mixture then precipitated with 100% ethanol. The DNA is pelleted after the precipitation step, washed with 70% ethanol, and resuspended in Tris-EDTA buffer.
For each gene and locus responsible for USH, at least two microsatellite markers were selected on the basis of their map position and heterozygosity coefficient. Fluorescent dye-labeled microsatellite markers were genotyped for all the participating family members. We used the True Allele PCR Premix (Applied Biosystems, Foster City, CA) for PCR reactions according to the manufacturer’s instructions. Briefly, we assembled a 15 ml reaction containing 9 ml true allele PCR premix, 10 pmole of a mix of forward and reverse primers, and 50 ng of genomic DNA. PCR conditions were as follows: 11 min at 94 °C followed by 35 cycles, each consisting of 15 s at 94 °C, 15 s at 55 °C, and 30 s at 72 °C, then a final elongation at 72 °C. Fluorescently labeled alleles were analyzed on an ABI PRISM 3100-Avant automated genetic analyzer (Applied Biosystems). Genotypes were determined using the GenScan™ and GenoTyper™ software (Applied Biosystems).
One affected subject was investigated for the presence of a mutation in MYO7A. Amplified products of all coding exons and exon–intron junctions were directly sequenced using an ABI 3100-Avant automated DNA sequencer and Big Dye Terminator Sequencing V3.1 kit (Applied Biosystems). Screening of the c.1935G>A mutation in the family was performed using PCR-restriction fragment length polymorphism. PCR amplification of a 349 bp DNA fragment, including exon 16 of the MYO7A gene, was performed with the primers MYO7A16F (5′ACC TCC CCT CCC GCT TCC T3′) and MYO7A16R (5′-GCC CCC CAT TCC CCA AAG G-3′). PCR products were digested with 10 U of NcoI restriction endonuclease (New England Biolabs, Ipswich, MA) for 1 h at 37 °C. Digestion of the wild-type allele yielded two fragments of 223 bp and 126 bp, while the mutation abolished the NcoI site.
The MYO7A sequence (accession number Q13402 in the UniProtKB/Swiss-Protdatabase) was submitted to a Basic Local Alignment Search Tool (BLAST)  search against the structures in the protein data bank (PDB) to find suitable templates for homology modeling. The myosin II motor domain from Dictyostelium discoideum was found to be the best homolog, with 42% amino acid sequence identity (PDB 1d0x, 2.0 Å resolution ) for the query search. The alignment of the myosin VIIa sequence against the template sequence was used as input to the MODELER program , together with the atomic coordinates of the latter. Fifty homology models were built by MODELER. The model having the lowest value of the MODELER objective function was selected and was improved by energy minimization. The stereochemical quality of the selected model was evaluated using the PROCHECK program . Swiss-Pdb Viewer  was used for structural analyses and to generate the p.M645I mutant model. ConSeq  and GetArea version 1.1 using a sphere probe radius of 1.4 Å  were used to analyze solvent accessibility surface.
To validate in silico prediction of the impact of the c.1935G>A mutation on splicing, wild-type and corresponding mutated genomic fragments were subcloned into expression vectors p(13,17)/cytomegalovirus (CMV) and transfected into HeLa cells. Amplification of MYO7A exon 16 and surrounding intronic sequences was performed using a forward primer (5′-TGA GGT AAC CAA GTC CGA TTA CTC CTT-3′) and a reverse primer (5′-GTG CTA GCG GGC ATC TGC AAG CAT TAC T-3′). Sequence mismatches were introduced to create BstEII and NheI restriction sites (bold letters). These primers led to an 892-bp PCR product. PCR conditions were as follows: 5 min at 94 °C followed by 40 cycles, each consisting of 30 s at 94 °C, 30 s at 66 °C, and 50 s at 72 °C, then a final elongation at 72 °C for 10 min. The PCR products were digested with BstEII and NheI restriction endonucleases and inserted at the BstEII/NheI sites of the splicing cassette p(13,17)/CMV that was designed to contain the two adjacent constitutive exons 13 and 17 of the human 4.1R gene with their downstream and upstream flanking intron sequences, respectively . The constructs were further sequenced to ascertain the absence of additional sequence changes.
HeLa cells were cultured in Dulbecco’s modified Eagle’s medium (Invitrogen, Karlsruhe, Germany)with 10% fetal calf serum in four well plates. Cells were transfected with 2 μg of wild-type or mutated minigene constructs, using FuGENE 6 Transfection Reagent (Roche Diagnostics Ltd, Lewes, UK), according to the manufacturer’s procedures. Briefly, a mixture of 95 μl of serum-free medium and 3 µl of FuGENE® 6 was vortexed and incubated for 5 min at room temperature, then, we added 2 μg of plasmid DNA into the tube. After incubation at room temperature, we added the transfection reagent to the cells in a drop-wise manner. Stably transfected cells were selected for 10–12 days in the same medium containing 600–800 μg Geneticin G418/ml (Invitrogen).
HeLa cells were washed twice with Ca2+/Mg2+-free phosphate-buffered saline (PBS; 1X), collected by trypsinization, and centrifuged. Isolation of total RNA was performed using TRIZOL reagents (Invitrogen), according to the manufacturer’s protocol. RNA was reverse transcribed, and cDNAs were used as templates for PCR amplification using the forward and reverse primers within the cassette’s upstream (UE, 4.1R exon 13) and downstream (DE, 4.1R exon 17) exons, as previously described . Direct sequencing of reverse transcriptase (RT)-PCR products was performed by standard conditions.
The effect of a splice site mutation was also assessed by RT–PCR analysis of lymphoid RNAs obtained from affected and control individuals. Total RNA was isolated from 10 ml of blood samples, using PureLink™ Micro-to-Midi Total RNA Purification System (Invitrogen). Reverse transcription was performed using oligo-dT primers and 200 U of M-MuLV (Moloney Murine Leukemia Virus) Reverse Transcriptase (Fermentas, St. Leon-Rot, Germany). The PCR step was performed using forward primer 5′-AGA CCC AGT TTG GCA TCA AC-3′ (exon 14) and reverse primer 5′-ATT CCT GAG TAC CGC AGC TGG-3′ (exon 17) and was expected to yield a 346-bp fragment.
An audiometric test performed in patients from the Tunisian family showed severe to profound bilateral sensorineural HL. Deaf individuals who underwent a caloric test had vestibular areflexia. Clinical interviews ruled out any history of a delay in the age of walking. The ophthalmological investigation in this family showed variability in the clinical onset and diagnosis of RP among patients. Individual MB9 (40 years old), her brother (37 years old), and her uncle (77 years old) had similar mild RP (Figure 1). In these individuals, night blindness was reported in the third decade. A visual field test and ERG was performed only in individual MB9. The visual field (Goldmann targets III/4e) was significantly reduced to a 5° concentric field and temporal island fields for both eyes. The nasal and temporal fields were not preserved, and only the central field was maintained (Figure 1). The Ganzfeld-ERG showed an almost normal response flash visual-evoked potential in both eyes and a significant bilateral global retinal degeneration. Only cone flicker responses of less than 15% of the normal mean were recordable under photopic conditions, while all other responses were below noise level, a typical finding for patients with retinitis pigmentosa (Figure 1). Fundus examination of MB9’s non-consanguineous husband (47 years of age) showed only a slight waxy pallor of the optic disc, so the absence of severe retinal degeneration as indicated by thinning and loss of pigment epithelium. Their daughters (15 and 9 years old) did not show any anomaly in funduscopy.
In an attempt to identify the altered gene, we first performed a genetic linkage analysis of fluorescent dye-labeled polymorphic microsatellite markers covering all known loci for USH. This analysis revealed evidence for a linkage to MYO7A mapping to chromosome 11q13.5 (Figure 1). All affected individuals showed a homozygous haplotype. Direct sequencing of MYO7A in one affected individual revealed a G to A transition (c.1935G>A) in the homozygous state. Co-segregation of the transition with HL in the family was confirmed by PCR-restriction fragment length polymorphism. This mutation is located in the last position of exon 16 and would potentially substitute an isoleucine for a methionine at position 645 of the protein (p.M645I).
A model covering the myosin motor domain from residue Val2 to Gln752 was built using the crystal structure of the myosin-II heavy chain from D. discoideum (PDB 1d0x, 2.0 Å resolution) as a template. The region encoded by exon 16 is located in the middle of this domain, which encodes the HW helix, the third strand of the central seven-stranded β sheet, and two loops (Figure 2). This portion of the protein is highly conserved among myosin VIIA homologs and seems to play an important role in the communication between the actin interface and nucleotide-binding pocket . ConSeq and GetArea results predict that p.Met645, which belongs to a loop between the third strand of the central seven-stranded β sheet and the SH2 helix, is a solvent-exposed residue. The replacement of this solvent-exposed residue with isoleucine does not perturb the native structure. In addition, this mutation is quite distant from the nucleotide and actin-binding sites. Altogether these predictions did not support a major functional impact of the amino acid substitution on protein function. We therefore hypothesized that the genomic mutation must have rather an earlier impact on mRNA metabolism.
The c.1935G>A mutation occurs at the last position of exon 16. We used the two splice site prediction programs Neural Network Splice Site Prediction Tool and Splice view to evaluate the strength of the altered splice site. The wild-type sequence resulted in predicted scores of 0.92 and 0.90, while the calculated values of the numerical score for the altered sequence were 0.62 and 0.60, respectively. These data suggest a weakening of the exon 16 donor site caused by the c.1935G>A mutation.
To investigate the possible effect of the mutation on mRNA splicing, we performed an RT–PCR analysis of total lymphocyte RNA obtained from the patient. The control sample displayed an expected band of 346 bp, containing exons 14 to 17. An additional faint band appeared in the control; it corresponded to an mRNA species missing exon 16 (Figure 3). This pattern was consistently encountered in six tested control individuals (data not shown). This observation suggests that exon 16 must be alternatively spliced, at least in lymphocytes. In the patient however, the splicing pattern showed rather a predominant exclusion of the exon (Figure 3).
To know if the altered splicing is due to the unique mutation found in exon 16, we used a transfected minigene approach to address the functional impact of the c.1935G>A mutation on exon 16 splicing. A genomic fragment of 892 bp containing exon 16 and flanking intron 15 and intron 16 sequences was cloned into an efficient splicing cassette. Control and mutated minigene constructs were stably transfected in HeLa cells. RT–PCR analysis performed on total RNA extracted from transfected cells faithfully reproduced the effects observed in vivo (Figure 3). The minigene splicing pattern obtained from the normal construct revealed a major 374-bp fragment, and a minor 246-bp product. The mutated construct also displayed the two different transcripts, with a predominant shorter band of 246 bp and a faint 374-bp fragment. The proportion (%) of mis-spliced transcripts compared to the full-length transcript was 62%. The percentage was measured using the Quantity One software (Bio-Rad, Marnes-La-Coquette, France; Figure 3). Direct sequencing revealed that the 374 bp contains exon 16, whereas the 246-bp PCR product is lacking the exon. These results strongly suggest that the unique c.1935G>A nucleotide change alters MYO7A pre-mRNA splicing and results in a switch from predominant inclusion to predominant skipping of exon 16.
Exon 16 skipping leads to the loss of the HW helix and the third strand of the central seven-stranded β sheet. The HW helix contains the actin-binding motif, and the strand is part of the central β sheet or transducer region, which concerted distortion led to conformational changes of the motor domain. Therefore, deletion of exon 16 would most likely affect the conformation of MYO7A and would result in a functionally altered allele.
The presence of RP is the crucial trait differentiating Usher syndrome from nonsyndromic HL. RP is defined simply as a progressive retinal dystrophy, identifiable by defective dark adaptation or nyctalopia (night blindness), reduction of the peripheral visual field (known as tunnel vision), appearance of “bony spicule” in the retina revealed by fundoscopy, and an abnormal or nonrecordable ERG . Five autosomal recessive nonsyndromic HL (DFNB2) families with MYO7A mutations were reported. In the Chinese, Iranian, and Pakistani families, the affected adults (>25 years of age) who had ophthalmologic examinations were almost normal [10,13,24]. Only one deaf patient (41 years old) in the Pakistani DFNB2 family had slightly subnormal rod and cone responses and a suboptimal quality ERG. However, RP in the Iranian DFNB2 family was ruled out by funduscopy excluding severe but not mild RP. The Tunisian family that enabled the defining of the DFNB2 locus was diagnosed with HL and vestibular dysfunction in 1994, but when reassessed 7 years later, five of 12 adult patients (>25 years of age) were found to have mild RP . The clinical presentation of the Tunisian family we describe in this report is noteworthy because of its similarity to the unrelated Tunisian DFNB2 family reported earlier .
To date, over 130 recessive mutations in MYO7A have been identified and are listed in the Human Gene Mutation Database. Almost all known MYO7A mutations cause USH1B. Six variations were described in five families with autosomal recessive nonsyndromic HL. In the Pakistani DFNB2 family, a correlation of clinical phenotype with the molecular phenotype was observed based on a myosin VIIa intracellular targeting assay. Riazuddin et al.  showed that the p.E1716del mutation of myosin VIIa has residual function in the inner ear. However, variations identified in the Chinese and the Iranian DFNB2 families did not document a relationship between the type and location of the MYO7A mutations in USH1B and recessive nonsyndromic phenotype. In the Chinese family designated DFNB.05, affected individuals are compound heterozygotes for a splice acceptor consensus site mutation (c.19–2A4G) in intron 3, and a T insertion mutation in exon 28 (p.V1199fsX1228) of MYO7A [24,25]. Both of these mutations are predicted to result in premature translation termination, and to date all such predicted truncating alleles of MYO7A gene are associated with USH. The p.R244 residue, affected in the Chinese family DFNB.01, is located near the open edge of the large cleft separating the upper 50 kDa from the lower 50K domain . The cleft is thought to close upon binding to actin and open upon dissociation. Introduction of a proline would alter the ability of the cleft to open and close properly upon binding to actin. Proline would also disrupt the hydrogen bond between p.R244 and p.D396 amino acids. The GFP-tagged mouse ortholog of p.R244P (GFP-myosin VIIa [p.R233P]) showed little or no GFP fluorescence within stereocilia, as observed for mutations associated with USH1 . The p.R395H mutation described in the Iranian DFNB2 family affects a residue immediately adjacent to the p.D396. The p.R395 residue, located in the motor domain of myosin VIIa, is exposed and highly conserved across species. The p.R395H mutation induced a local change in charge that likely compromises the structure and/or function of the motor domain. The p.R395 and p.D396 residues are adjacent to p.A397. Watanabe et al.  showed that the p.A397D missense mutation associated with USH abolished the actin-activated ATPase activity completely.
In the Tunisian DFNB2 families, the mutation lies at the last nucleotide of exon 16 of the MYO7A gene. Modeling analysis has led us to predict that the resultant amino acid change does not impair the structure and the activity of the protein. RNA analyses revealed that exon 16 is slightly excluded in control lymphocytes and that the c.1935G>A mutation triggers enhanced exon skipping. This finding is consistent with our hypothesis that c.1935G>A causes a less severe molecular phenotype than the USH1B-associated alleles. In a mice model Schwander et al.  showed that the (c.5742+5G>A) mutation, which affects splicing of the MYO7A transcript and truncates the myosin VIIa tail domain, leads to tissue-specific effects on protein levels. In the inner ear, expression of truncated myosin VIIa is severely reduced, whereas in RPE cells, the truncated myosin VIIa is expressed at levels similar to the wild-type protein level.
Previous works have reported four MYO7A variants localized at the last position of an exon affecting the G nucleotide at position −1 of donor splice sites. Thus c.592G>A (p.Ala198Thr), c.1687G>A (p.G563S), (c.3503G>C (p.Arg1168Pro), and c.5944G>A (p.Gly1982Arg) were described in families with USH1B. All these sequence variations were shown to globally weaken the natural 5′ splice site and to induce aberrant splicing. Transcripts resulting from the c.1687G>A mutation were undetectable . Minigene studies revealed that c.592G/A, c.3503G/C, and c.5944G/A variants are associated with moderate to high levels of exon skipping . The percentages of mis-spliced transcripts compared to the full-length transcript were respectively 76, 62, and 100%. Although exon skipping is partial in c.592G/A and c.3503G/C mutations and comparable to what we described in Tunisian families, they result in a more severe phenotype. This can be explained by the fact that they occur in compound heterozygotes with a missense p.G163R and a nonsense p.R150X mutation, respectively. These mutations also result in out-of-frame splice products, which would elicit the altered mRNA to degradation by Nonsense-Mediated mRNA Decay (NMD) , whereas the c.1935G>A mutation results in in-frame transcript.
In this study, we established that the c.1935G>A mutation identified in Tunisian families with HL and variable expression of RP results in the partial skipping of exon 16. We conclude that the residual function of myosin VIIa may result in DFNB or Usher phenotypes. Other environmental and/or genetic factors might have an impact on the RP phenotype. In this regard, subtle variations in splicing regulation have been recently emphasized regarding the use of the 5′ splice sites [32,33].
We are indebted to the family members for their invaluable
cooperation and for providing the blood samples. This research was
funded by Ministère de l’Enseignement Supérieur et de la Recherche
Scientifique, Tunisia, the European Commission FP6 Integrated Project
EUROHEAR, LSHG-CT-20054–512063, the “INSERM” and the “Région
Rhône-Alpes”. We thank Dr. Mohamed Grati for critical reading of the