|Molecular Vision 2006;
Received 25 January 2006 | Accepted 10 April 2006 | Published 10 April 2006
Expanding the mutational spectrum in TGFBI-linked corneal dystrophies: Identification of a novel and unusual mutation (Val113Ile) in a family with granular dystrophy
Juan Carlos Zenteno,1,2
Arturo Ramirez-Miranda,1 Concepción Santacruz-Valdes,3
Departments of 1Genetics and 3Cornea, and the 2Research Unit, Institute of Ophthalmology "Conde de Valenciana," Mexico City, Mexico
Correspondence to: Juan Carlos Zenteno, MD, PhD. Departamento de Genetica, Instituto de Oftalmologia "Conde de Valenciana," Chimalpopoca 14, Col. Obrera, Mexico City, 06800, Mexico; Phone: (5255) 55 88 46 00 ext 212; FAX: (5255) 55 88 46 00 ext 214; email: firstname.lastname@example.org
Purpose: To report the clinical and molecular study of a family with an autosomal dominant stromal granular dystrophy of the cornea caused by a novel and unusual TGFBI gene mutation.
Methods: A complete ophthalmological examination, corneal dystrophy phenotype characterization, PCR amplification, and automated nucleotidic sequencing of exons 4, 11,12, 13, and 14 of the TGFBI gene was carried out on the family. DNA from 40 unrelated ethnically matched healthy individuals were analyzed as controls.
Results: Corneal dystrophy in two sisters was characterized by multiple grayish-white lesions located in the anterior and mid-stroma. Numerous small sized non-coalescent opacities were observed in the peripheral cornea while fewer larger lesions were apparent towards the central part of the cornea. A heterozygous missense mutation, consisting of a G to A transition at nucleotide position 384 in TGFBI exon 4 that predicts a valine (GTT) to isoleucine (ATT) replacement in residue 113 (Val113Ile) of the TGFBI protein was identified.
Conclusions: This is the most 5' located mutation detected so far in subjects with TGFBI-linked corneal dystrophy. Valine 113 is strictly conserved in TGFBI from several species and we suggest that the phenotype observed in these patients is related to the unusual location of the mutation. Our results expand the mutational spectrum in the group of TGFBI-linked corneal dystrophies.
Corneal dystrophies (CDs) are a group of hereditary conditions characterized by the progressive accumulation of deposits on different layers of the cornea, with the resulting loss of refractive index and transparency. They are clinically and genetically heterogeneous disorders that typically initiate in the first or second decades of life, affect the central part of the cornea, and are not associated with inflammatory processes . Over time, the deposits can lead to visual impairment. Surgical procedures are frequently required to restore visual acuity. Present classifications of CDs are based upon both the layer of the cornea that is affected and the biomicroscopic characteristics of the deposits . Most CDs are inherited as autosomal dominant traits with intra- and interfamilial variable clinical expressivity and a high degree of penetrance .
The molecular genetics approach to subjects and families with different types of CDs has allowed the recognition of a group of autosomal dominant dystrophies that arise from a common pathogenetic mechanism represented by recurrent mutations in the 5q31-located (transforming growth factor-β induced TGFBI, also known as BIGH3) gene [2,4-8]. Over the past few years, it has been evident that specific TGFBI mutations strongly correlate to particular forms of CDs. To date, approximately 30 distinct TGFBI gene mutations have been demonstrated in patients of several ethnic groups with four distinct autosomal dominant Bowman's layer/stromal corneal dystrophies: granular CD type I [6-8], granular CD type II or Avellino type [6,8,9], granular CD type III (Reis-Bücklers dystrophy) [8,10,11], and Lattice CD of types I, IIIA, I/IIIA, IIIB, and IV [12-14]. Extracellular deposition of insoluble protein aggregates within the cornea is the hallmark of inherited corneal disorders caused by mutations in TGFBI [15,16].
The most common type of granular dystrophy is type I, also known as classic granular corneal dystrophy or Groenouw CD, which is characterized by multiple discrete crumb-like corneal opacities . The condition usually becomes apparent in the first decade of life or in puberty with grayish-white opacities that involve the superficial stromal layers of the cornea [18,19]. The lesions tend to aggregate, expand, and increase in number, spreading both peripherally and more deeply although a clear zone around the corneoescleral limbus remains typically present. Central disk-shaped opacities are formed after the third or fourth decade of life. Visual acuity gradually decreases and affected subjects may maintain unaffected vision for a long time . A striking genotype-phenotype correlation is evident in granular CD type I as almost all subjects suffering this disease have a C to T transition at nucleotide position 1,710 of TGFBI exon 12, predicting an Arg555Trp change in the protein [2,4,6-8]. However, in at least two unrelated subjects, the granular CD type I phenotype has been shown to be the result of a C to A transversion at nucleotide 417 of exon 4, causing a Arg124Ser substitution in TGFB1 [6,20]
In this paper we describe the clinical and molecular data of a Mexican family with an autosomal dominant granular dystrophy in which a novel TGFBI Val113Ile mutation was identified. This is the most 5' mutation described so far in the group of TGFBI-linked CDs, and our data suggest that the phenotypic peculiarities observed are related to the unusual location of the mutation.
The initial patient was a Mexican female aged 26 years who presented at the Institute of Ophthalmology "Conde de Valenciana" in Mexico City asking for refractive surgery due to previously diagnosed myopia. Ophthalmologic examination revealed best-corrected visual acuity of 20/20, intraocular pressure of 16 mm Hg, no anatomic defects of the anterior segment, transparent lenses, and normal funduscopy in both eyes. Biomicroscopic inspection of the cornea revealed bilateral, symmetric, sharply demarcated grayish-white opacities localized to the corneal stroma. The opacities showed a "centrifuge" distribution with numerous small (less than 2 mm in diameter) non-coalescent opacities located at the periphery and few larger lesions toward the most central part of the cornea (Figure 1, Figure 2). The intervening stroma between the opacities was clear. The lesions were located at the anterior and midstroma (Figure 3) while the overlying epithelium and underlying endothelium were both unaffected. No epithelial erosions nor stromal haze were noted at this age. A 23-year-old sister (visual acuity of 20/25 in both eyes) exhibited identical findings in both corneas. No accompanying somatic anomalies were noted in either patient. Their father, aged 55 years, was unavailable for clinical and molecular study but he was reported as having been diagnosed with a bilateral "degenerative corneal disease" which was evident by the third decade of life.
After obtaining local Institutional Ethics Committee approval and informed consent from patients, DNA was extracted from peripheral blood leukocytes of the proband and her affected sister, according to standard procedures. PCR amplification of exons 4, 11, 12, 13, and 14 of the TGFBI gene was achieved using four pairs of primers previously described . Each 25 μl PCR amplification reaction contained 1X PCR buffer, 100-200 ngs of genomic DNA, 0.2 mM of each dNTP, 1 unit Taq polymerase, 1 mM of forward and reverse primers, and 1.5 mM MgCl2. PCR products were analyzed in 1.5% agarose gels from which the bands with the amplified templates were excised and the DNA subsequently purified with the help of the Qiaex II kit (Qiagen, Hilden, Germany). Direct sequencing was performed with the BigDye Terminator Cycle Sequencing kit (Applied Biosystems, Foster City, CA) adding about 10 ng of template DNA in each reaction and using a temperature program which included 25 cycles of denaturation at 97 °C for 30 s, annealing at 50 °C for 15 s, and extension at 60 °C for four min. All samples were analyzed in an ABI Prism 310 Genetic Analyzer (Applied Biosystems). Sequence variations were confirmed in both sense and antisense DNA strands using a newly PCR amplified fragment. Forty DNA samples (80 TGFBI alleles) from normal Mexican people were analyzed as controls. Sequences were compared with the nucleotide and deduced amino acid sequence of published TGFBI cDNA (Ensembl ENST00000305126).
After sequencing the PCR product spanning exon 4 of the TGFBI gene in DNA from the proband, we identified a heterozygous missense mutation consisting of a G to A transition at nucleotide position 384 in exon 4 that predicts a valine (GTT) to isoleucine (ATT) replacement in TGFBI protein residue 113 (Val113Ile; Figure 4). This change is located in the region coding for the TGFBI FAS1-1 helix α1 domain, and it was absent in DNA from 80 control chromosomes, excluding the possibility of being a rare polymorphism. As this particular mutation does not create or abolish a restriction enzyme site, all samples were directly sequenced. The same mutation was identified in genomic DNA from the affected sister. The change was confirmed in both DNA strands in the patients. No additional pathogenetic nucleotide changes were detected in the examined TGFBI exons. A previously reported inconsequential polymorphic change (Phe540Phe) was also identified in our two patients.
Mutations in the TGFBI gene result in a variety of dominantly inherited dystrophies of the cornea that are classified according to the biomicroscopic features of the deposits and to its location within the corneal layers. At least four variants of granular CDs have been recognized (for a detailed review see reference ). Granular CD type I or classic granular dystrophy is distinguished by multiple discrete crumb-like corneal opacities in the anterior and mid-stroma commonly associated with painful epithelial erosions and almost exclusively caused by the R555W mutation in TGFBI. Granular CD type II or Avellino CD is characterized by stromal opacities shaped like rings, disks, stars, or snowflakes combined with linear opacities resembling some features of lattice CD. Epithelial erosions occur less often than in granular CD type I, and virtually all cases studied presented a TGFBI R124H mutation. Granular CD type III or superficial granular CD exhibits deposits that are morphologically identical from those observed in granular CD type I but are limited to the subepithelial region or the epithelium (most subjects have had the R124L mutation in TGFBI). Granular CD type IV, which is intermediate in severity between the classical and superficial variants, has been observed in a French family where it displayed round snowflake-shaped opacities in the subepithelial and most anterior stroma along with recurrent erosions that began in childhood. Notably, granular CD type IV affected patients carried two TGFBI mutations: R124L and a deletion of amino acids 125 and 126 . The phenotype found in our patients was not easily categorized under any of these four granular types, because a "centrifuge" pattern of opacities was observed with apparently most significant involvement of the peripheral than the central cornea. We consider that this phenotypic variation is related to the unusual location of the mutation in TGFBI. Unfortunately, the affected father was not examined. It is possible that in this family the corneal phenotype at an older age will be similar to the common types of granular dystrophies.
The TGFBI-expressed polypeptide is a 683 amino acids-long secreted protein containing four tandemly repeated domains of 140 residues which have a marked sequence similarity to the Drosophila melanogaster axonal guidance molecule fasciclin 1 (FAS1) . The four FAS1 domains in human TGFBI protein correspond to amino acids 134-236 (FAS1-1), 242-372 (FAS1-2), 373-501 (FAS1-3), and 502-632 (FAS1-4). To date, all mutations described in TGFBI associated to diverse types of CDs are located between residues 124 and 631 with the only two mutations described so far outside the fourth FASI domain (residues 502-632) being those affecting residues 501 (third FAS1 domain) and 124 (on the NH2-terminal side of FAS1 first domain). The mutation described in this paper is located in residue 113, which is 11 residues away from arginine 124, the most NH2-terminus located mutated residue in CDs . A BLASTP search revealed that valine residue at position 113 is strictly conserved in TGFBI proteins from different species as Pan troglodytes, Canis familiaris, Mus musculus, Bos Taurus, and Gallus gallus, suggesting that this amino acid is important for normal protein function. Valine 113 is located in the α1 helix of TGFBI FAS1-1 domain . Although there is indirect in vitro evidence that the presence of valine-valine at positions 112-113 may be important for blocking fibril formation , the role of valine 113 in TGFBI protein folding awaits further experimental investigations.
Inherited corneal disorders caused by mutations in TGFBI are associated with an extracellular deposition of insoluble protein aggregates within the cornea. These deposits can be amyloid (as seen in CD lattice type), granular/non-amyloid (in granular CD type I and CD Reiss-Bücklers), or a mixture of both (CD Avellino type) . The reason that amyloid deposition is a prominent manifestation of certain, but not all, TGFBI mutations remains to be established . Granular phenotypes in CDs result from missense mutations in three specific TGFBI amino acids (for a review see  and references therein); 555 (R555W mutation in almost all granular CD type I cases, R555Q in some cases of granular CD type III), 623 (in some cases of granular CD type III), and 124 (R124H in all cases of granular CD type II), R124L in most cases of granular CD type III and R124S in two unrelated subjects with a granular CD type I phenotype [6,20]. Thus, valine 113 is the fourth TGFBI residue whose missense mutations can result in a corneal granular dystrophy. Genetic analysis on more numerous groups of CD patients from different ethnic backgrounds will result in the recognition of nonclassic mutations, ultimately allowing a more accurate clinical-molecular classification of TGFBI-linked CDs.
The authors are grateful for the Patronage of the Fundacion "Conde de Valenciana" for financial support.
1. Chang SW, Tuli S, Azar DT. Corneal dystrophies. In: Traboulsi EI. Genetic diseases of the eye. New York: Oxford University Press; 1998: p. 217-66.
2. Klintworth GK. The molecular genetics of the corneal dystrophies--current status. Front Biosci 2003; 8:d687-713.
3. Klintworth GK. Advances in the molecular genetics of corneal dystrophies. Am J Ophthalmol 1999; 128:747-54.
4. Munier FL, Korvatska E, Djemai A, Le Paslier D, Zografos L, Pescia G, Schorderet DF. Kerato-epithelin mutations in four 5q31-linked corneal dystrophies. Nat Genet 1997; 15:247-51.
5. Korvatska E, Munier FL, Djemai A, Wang MX, Frueh B, Chiou AG, Uffer S, Ballestrazzi E, Braunstein RE, Forster RK, Culbertson WW, Boman H, Zografos L, Schorderet DF. Mutation hot spots in 5q31-linked corneal dystrophies. Am J Hum Genet 1998; 62:320-4.
6. Munier FL, Frueh BE, Othenin-Girard P, Uffer S, Cousin P, Wang MX, Heon E, Black GC, Blasi MA, Balestrazzi E, Lorenz B, Escoto R, Barraquer R, Hoeltzenbein M, Gloor B, Fossarello M, Singh AD, Arsenijevic Y, Zografos L, Schorderet DF. BIGH3 mutation spectrum in corneal dystrophies. Invest Ophthalmol Vis Sci 2002; 43:949-54.
7. Ellies P, Renard G, Valleix S, Boelle PY, Dighiero P. Clinical outcome of eight BIGH3-linked corneal dystrophies. Ophthalmology 2002; 109:793-7.
8. Afshari NA, Mullally JE, Afshari MA, Steinert RF, Adamis AP, Azar DT, Talamo JH, Dohlman CH, Dryja TP. Survey of patients with granular, lattice, avellino, and Reis-Bucklers corneal dystrophies for mutations in the BIGH3 and gelsolin genes. Arch Ophthalmol 2001; 119:16-22.
9. El-Ashry MF, Abd El-Aziz MM, Larkin DF, Clarke B, Cree IA, Hardcastle AJ, Bhattacharya SS, Ebenezer ND. A clinical, histopathological, and genetic study of Avellino corneal dystrophy in British families. Br J Ophthalmol 2003; 87:839-42.
10. Rozzo C, Fossarello M, Galleri G, Sole G, Serru A, Orzalesi N, Serra A, Pirastu M. A common beta ig-h3 gene mutation (delta f540) in a large cohort of Sardinian Reis Bucklers corneal dystrophy patients. Mutations in brief no. 180. Online. Hum Mutat 1998; 12:215-6.
11. Okada M, Yamamoto S, Tsujikawa M, Watanabe H, Inoue Y, Maeda N, Shimomura Y, Nishida K, Quantock AJ, Kinoshita S, Tano Y. Two distinct kerato-epithelin mutations in Reis-Bucklers corneal dystrophy. Am J Ophthalmol 1998; 126:535-42.
12. Chakravarthi SV, Kannabiran C, Sridhar MS, Vemuganti GK. TGFBI gene mutations causing lattice and granular corneal dystrophies in Indian patients. Invest Ophthalmol Vis Sci 2005; 46:121-5.
13. Aldave AJ, Gutmark JG, Yellore VS, Affeldt JA, Meallet MA, Udar N, Rao NA, Small KW, Klintworth GK. Lattice corneal dystrophy associated with the Ala546Asp and Pro551Gln missense changes in the TGFBI gene. Am J Ophthalmol 2004; 138:772-81.
14. Chau HM, Ha NT, Cung LX, Thanh TK, Fujiki K, Murakami A, Kanai A. H626R and R124C mutations of the TGFBI (BIGH3) gene caused lattice corneal dystrophy in Vietnamese people. Br J Ophthalmol 2003; 87:686-9.
15. Korvatska E, Munier FL, Chaubert P, Wang MX, Mashima Y, Yamada M, Uffer S, Zografos L, Schorderet DF. On the role of kerato-epithelin in the pathogenesis of 5q31-linked corneal dystrophies. Invest Ophthalmol Vis Sci 1999; 40:2213-9.
16. Klintworth GK, Bao W, Afshari NA. Two mutations in the TGFBI (BIGH3) gene associated with lattice corneal dystrophy in an extensively studied family. Invest Ophthalmol Vis Sci 2004; 45:1382-8.
17. Collin HB, Hendicott PL. Granular dystrophy of the cornea. Clin Exp Optom 1999; 82:203-206.
18. Moller HU. Granular corneal dystrophy Groenouw type I. Clinical and genetic aspects. Acta Ophthalmol Suppl 1991; 198:1-40.
19. Haddad R, Font RL, Fine BS. Unusual superficial variant of granular dystrophy of the cornea. Am J Ophthalmol 1977; 83:213-8.
20. Stewart HS, Ridgway AE, Dixon MJ, Bonshek R, Parveen R, Black G. Heterogeneity in granular corneal dystrophy: identification of three causative mutations in the TGFBI (BIGH3) gene-lessons for corneal amyloidogenesis. Hum Mutat 1999; 14:126-32.
21. Dighiero P, Drunat S, D'Hermies F, Renard G, Delpech M, Valleix S. A novel variant of granular corneal dystrophy caused by association of 2 mutations in the TGFBI gene-R124L and DeltaT125-DeltaE126. Arch Ophthalmol 2000; 118:814-8.
22. Zinn K, McAllister L, Goodman CS. Sequence analysis and neuronal expression of fasciclin I in grasshopper and Drosophila. Cell 1988; 53:577-87.
23. Clout NJ, Hohenester E. A model of FAS1 domain 4 of the corneal protein beta(ig)-h3 gives a clearer view on corneal dystrophies. Mol Vis 2003; 9:440-8 <http://www.molvis.org/molvis/v9/a56/>.
24. Schmitt-Bernard CF, Chavanieu A, Herrada G, Subra G, Arnaud B, Demaille JG, Calas B, Argiles A. BIGH3 (TGFBI) Arg124 mutations influence the amyloid conversion of related peptides in vitro. Eur J Biochem 2002; 269:5149-56.