Molecular Vision 2016; 22:1169-1175
Received 12 May 2016 | Accepted 10 October 2016 | Published 12 October 2016
1National Optometry Centre, Dublin Institute of Technology, Dublin, Ireland; 2School of Biological Sciences, Dublin Institute of Technology, Dublin, Ireland
Correspondence to: Siobhan Eustace Ryan, National Optometry Centre, Dublin Institute of Technology, Kevin Street, Dublin 8, Ireland; Phone: 353 1 4024900, FAX: 353 1 4024915; email: firstname.lastname@example.org
Purpose: Approximately 95% of patients who are diagnosed with Leber’s hereditary optic neuropathy (LHON) have one of three mitochondrial point mutations responsible for the disease, G3460A, G11778A, and T14484C. The purpose of this study was to develop a novel multiplex real-time amplification-refractory mutation system (ARMS) PCR combined with high-resolution melt curves to identify the individual mutations involved. The study aimed to provide a more robust, cost- and time-effective mutation detection strategy than that offered with currently available methods. The assay reported in this study will allow diagnostic laboratories to avoid costly next-generation sequencing (NGS) assays for most patients with LHON and to focus resources on patients with unknown mutations that require further analysis.
Methods: The test uses a combination of multiplex allele-specific PCR (ARMS PCR) in combination with a high-resolution melt curve analysis to detect the presence of the mutations in G3460A, G11778A, and T14484C. PCR primer sets were designed to produce a control PCR product and PCR products only in the presence of the mutations in 3460A, 11778A, and 14484C in a multiplex single tube format. Products produce discrete well-separated melt curves to clearly detect the mutations.
Results: This novel real-time ARMS PCR/high-resolution melt curve assay accurately detected 95% of the mutations that cause LHON. The test has proved to be robust, cost- and time-effective with the real-time closed tube system taking approximately 1 h to complete.
Conclusions: A novel real-time ARMS PCR/high-resolution melt curve assay is described for the detection of the three primary mitochondrial mutations in LHON. This test provides a simple, robust, easy-to-read output that is cost- and time-effective, thus providing an alternative method to individual endpoint PCR-restriction fragment length polymorphism (RFLP), PCR followed by Sanger sequencing or pyrosequencing, and next-generation sequencing.
Leber’s hereditary optic neuropathy (LHON; OMIM 535000) is an inherited neuropathy caused by primary mtDNA mutations leading to bilateral optic atrophy [1,2]. As a result, visual prognosis is poor with the majority of patients with LHON registered as legally blind. This profound loss of vision in affected subjects is due to the targeted destruction of the highly specialized retinal ganglion cells (RGCs) . Patients with LHON usually present initially with painless, subacute loss of vision in one eye, with the second eye becoming affected in the following weeks to months.
LHON has a prevalence of 1 in 31,000 in northern England, 1 in 39,000 in the Netherlands, and 1 in 50,000 in Finland [4-6]. The disease typically affects a young demographic, with peak onset between the ages of 15 and 30 years . Patient carriers of LHON mutations who have not experienced any loss of vision before age 50 are likely not to do so.
However, several patients with LHON have suffered visual failure from as young as 2 years and as old as 87 years of age . LHON demonstrates distinctive clinical signs, such as incomplete penetrance and an obvious gender bias with approximately 50% of male carriers and only 10% of female carriers developing the disease , suggesting that other genetic factors and/or the environment must play a role in disease penetrance [10-12].
Approximately 95% of those diagnosed with LHON have one of three primary mitochondrial mutations affecting complex I subunits of the respiratory chain—G3460A (A52T of ND1), G11778A (R340H of ND4), and T14484C (M64V of ND6) [13-15]—while other rare mutations (such as G13730A, G14459A, C14482G, A14495G, C14498T, C14568T, and T14596A) account for the final 5% [16-23]. LHON specifically targets the RGCs that are highly susceptible to oxidative stress and mitochondrial dysfunction . Interestingly, some visual recovery can occur in patients with LHON, but the extent of this recovery is dependent upon the mutation involved in that patient’s LHON. The point mutation T14484C exhibits some visual recovery in (58%) of patients with LHON, followed by the point mutation G3460A at 25%. Patients who harbour the G11778A mutation have the lowest level of visual recovery [24-27].
Current diagnostic strategies for the three most common mutations that cause LHON include individual endpoint PCR-restriction fragment length polymorphism (RFLP) , multiplex PCR-RFLP , allele-specific PCR , real-time PCR , and PCR followed by Sanger sequencing or pyrosequencing . A targeted next-generation sequencing (NGS) panel is available for mitochondrial sequencing (mtSEEK®), and open source bioinformatics software is also available for extracting mitochondrial sequences from NGS exome sequences . This study aimed to develop a novel multiplex closed tube real-time assay to detect the three common mutations using a combination of allele-specific amplification and high-resolution melt curve analysis. The assay will allow diagnostic laboratories to avoid costly NGS for most LHON cases.
Patient DNAs were obtained from the Centre for Medical Genetics, Our Lady’s Hospital for Sick Children, Dublin, Ireland and Oxford Medical Genetics Laboratories, Oxford, UK. Subjects gave written consent for the testing of their DNA for the 3 primary mutations causing LHON. All subject samples used in this study were previously tested for the 3 primary mutations using simplex PCR and bidirectional DNA sequencing and the results reported. To maintain patient confidentiality, aliquots of residual DNA material from the diagnostic test were labelled with the LHON mutation detected and irreversibly anonymised. The use of subject DNA in this study has received ethical approval from the Dublin Institute of Technology Research Ethics Committee. This study adhered to the tenets of the Declaration of Helsinki and the ARVO statement on human subjects.
PCR primer sets (Sigma Genosys, Arklow, Ireland, Table 1) were designed to produce PCR products only in the presence of the 3460A, 11778A, and 14484C mutations and not in the presence of any of the wild-type sequences. The positions of the primers are highlighted in the complete mitochondrial genome (NCBI Reference Sequence; NC_012920.1) in Appendix 1. To control for DNA quality and PCR conditions, a control primer set was included that amplifies genomic insulin sequences (Table 1 and Appendix 2, NCBI Sequence: E00022.1). To clearly differentiate the control and mutation-specific PCR products in a multiplex melt curve analysis, the thermodynamic stability (melting temperature) of the PCR products was initially estimated using uMELT  software before experimental analysis in a single tube. All double-stranded DNA sequences have the property that the temperature at which they become single stranded is determined by the sequence composition and the length of the DNA sequence . Several different PCR products can thus be differentiated in a mixture, if the products each have different melting temperatures. The insulin control primer set (INS F/R) was chosen because of its own distinct melting point compared to the three mutations under investigation. A β-globin control primer set was also evaluated but not considered as the melting temperature was not easily distinguishable from that of the LHON mutations.
Simplex PCR for the determination of melting temperatures of individual PCR products was performed on an ABI 7500 Fast (Life Technologies, Carlsbad, CA) real-time PCR instrument in a reaction containing 50 ng of genomic DNA, 100 ng of the appropriate primer mix, and 7.5 μl of PowerUp SYBR Green Master Mix (Life Technologies) in a total volume of 15 μl. The PCR conditions were 95 °C for 2 min, followed by 35 cycles of 95 °C for 3 s, and 60.5 °C for 30 s. This was followed by melt curve analysis at 95 °C for 15 s, 60 °C for 1 min, and continuous detection up to 95 °C. For multiplex analysis, these cycling conditions were used on 50 ng of DNA and a primer mix containing 20 ng of 3460 amplification-refractory mutation system (ARMS) F/R, 35 ng of 11,778 ARMS F/R, 250 ng of 14,484 ARMS F/R, and 15 ng of INS F/R. During optimization of the protocol, products were also detected with electrophoresis on a 2.5% agarose gel (Life Technologies) containing 0.5 μg/ml ethidium bromide (catalogue no. E7637; Sigma Genosys, Arklow, Ireland).
The test is designed such that the control sequence will always produce a product, while the presence of one of the mutations will be detected by the additional amplification of the corresponding allele-specific PCR product. The presence of the control PCR product in the absence of any of the mutation-specific PCR products indicates the absence of the three mutations. The presence of the control product in the presence of one of the mutation-specific PCR products indicates the presence of the mutation. The resultant PCR products can be visualized (if required) on an ethidium bromide–stained agarose gel (Figure 1A), but the SYBR green dye and melting curves detect and differentiate the control and allele-specific products in real time. The melting temperatures of the 3460A, 11778A, 14484C, β–globin, and INS control products were 82.58 °C, 80.32 °C, 76.31 °C, 86.03 °C, and 90.24 °C, respectively, allowing clear differentiation of the allele-specific products as shown in Figure 1B. As the melting temperature of the INS product is significantly different from any of the allele-specific products, this product was chosen for the multiplex analysis.
Multiplex analysis using a combination of the three allele-specific primer sets and the INS control primer set provided clear and robust detection of the three mutations in the subject control samples as demonstrated in Figure 2. Figure 3 shows the four samples on a 2.5% agarose gel and on a real-time melt curve screen, demonstrating the clear differentiation of the allele-specific products using melting temperatures.
This study aimed to develop a novel ARMS PCR / high resolution melt curve-based multiplex assay for the detection of the three most common mutations leading to LHON. Approximately 95% of patients with LHON have one of the three common mutations, G3460A (13%), G11778A (69%) and T14484C (14%), with other rare mutations accounting for the final 5%. This assay robustly detected the three primary mitochondrial mutations causing LHON in less than 1 h at a cost that is significantly lower than individual PCR-RFLP , multiplex PCR-RFLP , bidirectional Sanger sequencing or pyrosequencing sequencing , and next-generation sequencing methodologies . This assay provides a significant advantage over current technologies. As can be seen in Figure 1 and Figure 2, mutation identification in subjects is clear and robust. This assay could be implemented in any laboratory with a SYBR Green–capable real-time PCR machine and with minimal optimization and setup time. We suggest that the assay described will detect 95% of the mutations that cause LHON at minimal cost with a rapid turnaround time. The genetic testing registry (NCBI; accessed May 2016) shows that most LHON testing involves uni- or bidirectional Sanger sequencing targeted to the three primary mutations (n = 21), targeted simplex PCR-RFLP (n = 7), and other testing methods (including real-time mutation detection, PCR followed by hybridization and pyrosequencing; n = 4) with two laboratories offering a targeted 37 mitochondrial gene NGS panel (mtSEEK®). The assay described in this manuscript would allow many laboratories testing for LHON to rule out the established mutations 3460A, 11778A, and 14484C in 95% of tests, thus focusing NGS resources on the remaining 5% of test samples.
Contributors SER performed the molecular genetic studies, analyzed results and drafted the manuscript. FR conceived the study, participated in its design and helped to draft the manuscript. VOD and DN supervised the work and helped to draft and critically reviewed the manuscript. Funding This work was supported by a grant from Fight for Sight Ireland to SER. Ethics approval: The use of subject DNA in this study has received ethical approval from the Dublin Institute of Technology Research Ethics Committee.