Molecular Vision 2021; 27:323-353
<http://www.molvis.org/molvis/v27/323>
Received 25 November 2020 | Accepted 11 May 2021 | Published 13 May 2021
Molecular Vision 2021; 27:323-353
<http://www.molvis.org/molvis/v27/323>
Received 25 November 2020 |
Accepted 11 May 2021 |
Published 13 May 2021
Daniela Rodrigues-Braz,1 Min Zhao,1 Nilufer Yesilirmak,1,2,3 Selim Aractingi,4 Francine Behar-Cohen,1,3 Jean-Louis Bourges1,3
1Centre de Recherche des Cordeliers, Université de Paris, Sorbonne Université, Inserm, UMRS1138, Team 17, Physiopathology of ocular diseases: therapeutic innovations, Paris, France; 2Department of Ophthalmology, Ankara Yildirim Beyazit University, Ankara, Turkey; 3Ophtalmopole, Assistance Publique -Hôpitaux de Paris (AP-HP), Cochin Hospital, Paris, France; 4Department of Dermatology, AP-HP, Cochin Hospital, Paris, France
Correspondence to: Francine Behar-Cohen, Centre de Recherche des Cordeliers, Université de Paris, Sorbonne Université, Inserm, UMRS1138, Team 17, Physiopathology of ocular diseases: therapeutic innovations, 75006, Paris, France; Phone: +33 1 44 27 81 64; email: francine.behar@gmail.com
Rosacea is a chronic inflammatory disease that affects the face skin. It is clinically classified into the following four subgroups depending on its location and severity: erythematotelangiectatic, papulopustular, phymatous, and ocular. Rosacea is a multifactorial disease triggered by favoring factors, the pathogenesis of which remains imperfectly understood. Recognized mechanisms include the innate immune system, with the implication of Toll-like receptors (TLRs) and cathelicidins; neurovascular deregulation involving vascular endothelial growth factor (VEGF), transient receptor potential (TRP) ion channels, and neuropeptides; and dysfunction of skin sebaceous glands and ocular meibomian glands. Microorganisms, genetic predisposition, corticosteroid treatment, and ultraviolet B (UVB) radiation are favoring factors. In this paper, we review the common and specific molecular mechanisms involved in the pathogenesis of cutaneous and ocular rosacea and discuss laboratory and clinical studies, as well as experimental models.
Rosacea is a chronic inflammatory disease that mainly affects the central facial skin (cheeks, chin, nose, and central forehead); it is characterized by flushing, transient or persistent rash, inflammatory papules and pustules, telangiectasia, and ocular manifestations [1-3]. According to its clinical presentation, it has been classified by the National Committee of Experts into the four following subtypes: erythematotelangiectatic, papulopustular, phymatous, and ocular [4].
Rosacea affects about 10% of the population with a greater risk of sun-sensitive fair skin [5]; the disease can also develop in Asian and African populations [6]. The severity of the disease appears to depend on the patient’s gender and age, where rosacea is three times more frequent in women than in men but more severe in men and younger patients, suggesting that the more severe forms of the disease manifest sooner or that the disease improves over time [7]. The ocular variant of rosacea represents between 10% and 50% of the total rosacea population and is characterized by inflammation of the ocular surface tissues, including the eyelid edge (blepharitis) and eyes (tear film instability, eye irritation, red eyes, eye dryness, conjunctivitis, etc.) [8,9]. In the most severe cases, chronic corneal damage may lead to corneal neovascularization (CNV), corneal perforations, corneal ulcers, and corneal edemas, which compromise corneal transparency and lead to visual loss [3,10,11] (Figure 1).
To date, the diagnosis of rosacea has been established clinically based on observation and interpretation of skin and ocular signs. While many patients show both ocular and skin signs, some may only show ocular signs, which can make diagnosis more difficult [12-14].
The mechanisms of rosacea are still unclear. In recent years, a multifactorial pathogenesis with genetic predisposition has been emphasized [15]. Many triggering factors, such as ultraviolet (UV) exposure, local inflammatory responses to skin microorganisms (associated with Demodex infestation), temperature changes, hot, cold, spicy foods, and stress have been considered to initiate or worsen the disease [16]. In addition, studies have demonstrated an implication of the skin and ocular immune system with changes in adaptative and innate cells, as well as neuroinflammatory changes [17] (Figure 2). Involvement of innate immunity has been advocated by high expression of the Toll-like receptor 2 (TLR-2) and the antimicrobial peptide of cathelicidin (LL-37) in the skin tissues of rosacea patients. In addition, the nucleotide-binding domain leucin-rich repeat and pyrin-containing receptor 3 (NLRP3) inflammasome appear to play a role in LL-37-mediated inflammation [18]. The infiltration of mast cells and the release of proinflammatory mediators, such as interleukin-1β (IL-1β), IL-6, IL-17, interferon-γ (IFN-γ), matrix metalloproteinase-2 (MMP-2), MMP-9, tumor necrosis factor-α (TNF-α), activated by nuclear factor-κB (NF-κB) [19-21], as well as the infiltration of CD4(+) T cells, contribute to the inflammatory signs [22,23]. Abnormal neural control of vascular flow contributes to enlargement of skin and ocular surface blood vessels. Such vascular content increases appear to relate to elevated levels of vascular endothelial growth factor (VEGF) and transient receptor potential (TRP) channel found in rosacea patients [24,25]. However, it remains unclear whether such vascular changes are a primary event or a consequence of inflammatory changes.
Finally, the molecular steps involved in the pathogenesis of ocular rosacea are not fully known. Meibomian gland dysfunction has been recognized as a major component [13,26]. Like in the skin, activation of the innate and adaptive immune response and abnormal vascular regulations have been identified. In the tears and in the ocular surface tissues of ocular rosacea patients, high levels of TLR-4 and LL-37 were measured together with cell infiltration and the release of proinflammatory factors [13,27,28]. A link between Demodex infestation and ocular rosacea has also been advocated [29,30]. Overall, all these phenomena in the skin and eye act in synergy to maintain chronic inflammation at the cutaneous, epidermal, conjunctival, and perivascular interface, eventually leading to secondary fibrosis [31]. In this paper, we aim to review the common and specific pathogenic mechanisms of cutaneous and ocular rosacea and focus on the few models used to study this disease.
Activation of immune-mediated inflammatory pathways appears to be at the center of the pathogenesis of rosacea and involves the coordinated activity of several cell types, such as mast cells and macrophages, and the release of proinflammatory mediators, such as IL-6, IL-1β, IL-18, or TNF-α [32,33]. Inhibition of these inflammatory pathways is correlated with clinical improvement.
TLR-2/4 pathways-- As part of the innate immune system, members of the TLRs, which recognize physical and chemical stimuli or microbial pathogens, are expressed on the surface of various skin cells, including keratinocytes, macrophages, and mast cells [34]. Induction of the innate immune response by TLR stimulation induces the controlled and limited activation of NF-κB and the subsequent production of cytokines, chemokines, and antimicrobial peptides [35]. However, uncontrolled activation of the innate immune system leads to deleterious consequences [36].
In the skin of rosacea patients, TLR-2 is overexpressed on the keratinocytes in the epidermis and on infiltrating cells in the dermis [19,21], enhancing skin sensitivity to external stimuli and the production of IL-8, IL-1β, and TNF-α by keratinocytes [20,37]. TLR-2 can also activate the NLRP3 inflammasome and induce cell death [18,38]. Components of the inflammasome, including caspase-1 and IL-1β, in the rosacea skin [39] worsen the inflammatory response by activating many other proinflammatory factors, such as IL-8, TNF-α and MMPs [20]. The transcription factor NF-κB, activated by TNF-α or directly stimulated by TLRs or LL-37 signaling, induces the expression of IL-1α, IL-1β, IL-18, and IL-33 [40,41].
Recently, erythroid differentiation regulator 1 (Erdr1) has been recognized as a cytokine suppressed by TLR-2 and the myeloid differentiation factor 88 (MyD88) pathways. Indeed, animals deficient in TLR-2 and MyD88 have elevated Erdr1 [42]. Erdr1, localized at the inner part of the cytoplasmic membrane and secreted through vesicles immediately under stress conditions, has been shown to be reduced in rosacea skin [43]. Erdr1 is negatively regulated by IL-18, a proinflammatory cytokine, and has a biphasic effect. It enhances cell survival at low concentrations and densities but increases cell death at high concentrations and densities. Recombinant Erdr1 significantly reduced the disease in a rosacea model induced by the injection of LL-37 in rodents [43].
TLRs are also present at the ocular surface, where TLR-2 and 4 are constitutively expressed in the corneal, limbic, and conjunctival epithelial cells [44,45]. Stimulation of TLRs by exogenous stimuli activates NF-κB and induces the production of cytokines and antimicrobial peptides, such as β-defensins [46]. In corneal inflammation in mice and humans, the roles of TLR-2 and 4 have been recognized [47]. In eyelid biopsies of patients with ocular rosacea, TLR-4 expression was significantly increased compared with normal subjects [28], and high levels of TLR-2 and 4 were detected in various ocular surface conditions, including dry eye syndrome, one of the hallmarks of ocular rosacea. Activated TLR-4 has been shown to induce the activation of TLR-2 and together enhance the transcription of inducible nitric oxide synthase (iNOS) [21]. In a rodent model of dry eye disease, the corneal expression of TLR-4 was significantly increased. TLR-4 inhibition reduced the severity of dryness and the expression of IL-1β, IL-6, and TNF-α, as well as the corneal infiltration of CD4(+) T cells [48]. These results suggest that TLR-4 participates in inflammatory responses of the ocular surface. Furthermore, TLR-2 expression was upregulated in the conjunctival and corneal cells and in the lacrimal glands in a rodent model of dry eye, as well as in conjunctival cells of patients with dry eye [49,50].
In the eyelid biopsies of patients with rosacea, Wladis et al. [51,52] showed that the NF-κB pathway was significantly increased in rosacea patients. Furthermore, patients showed increased levels of active mitogen-activated protein kinase (MAPK) protein 38 (p38) and extracellular signal-regulated kinase (Erk) compared with healthy subjects, acting in concert with NF-κB factor for the regulation of immune responses. In addition, TLRs, including TLR-2, are well known for promoting increased activation of p38 and Erk signaling.
In tears, rosacea patients have increased levels of IL-1α, IL-1β, IL-16, TNF-α, monocyte chemoattractant protein-1 (MCP-1), MMP-8, and MMP-9 [53-57]. IL-1 can increase the production and activation of MMPs, including MMP-9, contributing to eyelid and ocular surface irritation, epithelial defects, corneal ulcers, and CNV observed in severe rosacea patients [14]. Proinflammatory factors can also be released by resident cells, such as mast cells, or subsequently by infiltrating cells.
Origin of cathelicidin in rosacea-- Cathelicidins, classified as antimicrobial peptides (AMPs), play a major role in mammalian innate immune defense against bacteria. In humans, the Camp gene encodes the precursor peptide 18-kDa cationic antimicrobial protein (CAP-18), which is cleaved by kallikrein-related peptidase 5 (KLK-5) into the active forms LL-37 and FALL-39 [58-60]. LL-37, a-37-amino-acid amphipathic and helical peptide, is expressed in epithelial cells and in leukocytes, such as monocytes, neutrophils, T cells, natural killer (NK) cells, and B cells. Different cell types produce this peptide, such as keratinocytes, myeloid cells, neutrophils, and mast cells. Many studies have shown enhanced LL-37 expression in the skin biopsies of rosacea patients [61-63]. Elevated expression levels and activity of KLK-5 have also been described in the skin of rosacea patients [62], as well as in other skin diseases, such as atopic dermatitis, Netherton syndrome, or psoriasis [64]. Injection of KLK-5 into the skin of mice has been shown to cause dermatitis alleviated by inhibition of KLK-5 activity [65]. In human epidermal cells stimulated with calcitriol, the hormonally active form of vitamin D—which is known to induce expression of KLK-5 and LL-37—the inhibition of KLK-5 expression was correlated with a significant decrease in the expression levels of IL-6, IL-18, and MCP-1 [66]. Increasing the expression of TLR-2 increased the expression of KLK-5, and conversely, showed a link between TLR-2 and KLK-5 activation in rosacea-affected skin [19].
In a recent study, Sugimoto et al. [67] found that the expression of a Kazal-type lymphoepithelial inhibitor (LEKTI) in keratinocytes, known to control the activity of KLK-5, was upregulated in the biopsies of rosacea patients. Thus, this molecule could participate in the control of the aberrant activity of KLK-5 in the inflammatory reactions of rosacea. In addition to its activation by TLR-2, KLK-5 can also be activated by MMP-9 in rosacea [16,68]. Therefore, KLK-5 activity is tightly regulated by a balance of activators, such as TLR-2 and MMP-9, and repressors, such as LEKTI.
The increase in cathelicidin levels in rosacea patients could be amplified via the expression of the protease-activated receptor 2 (PAR-2), which is activated by KLK-5 and known to mediate inflammation in various tissues, including the skin [69]. Kim et al. [70] showed that PAR-2 levels were higher in skin biopsies from rosacea patients and that keratinocytes stimulation with PAR-2 in vitro increased the production of LL-37, IL-6, and IL-8.
The link between LL-37 and rosacea was demonstrated by Yamasaki et al. [61] in an inflammatory skin mouse model induced by the injection of LL-37, developing telangiectasia, erythema, and inflammation. Using the same model, Yuan et al. [71] showed that the skin expressed higher levels of TNF-α, IL-1β, IL-6, and TLR-2 compared with the control group. The Janus kinase/signal transducers and activators of transcription (JAK/STAT) signal transduction pathway also appeared to participate in the inflammatory mechanism in cutaneous rosacea mediated by LL-37. Using in vitro HaCaT cells, a spontaneously immortalized human keratinocyte line, treated with LL-37, Li et al. [72], further demonstrated the upregulation of JAK2 and STAT3, which upregulated the expression of proinflammatory cytokines, including TNF-α, IL-6, IL-8, and MCP-1. The inhibition of this pathway was followed by a decrease in the production of proinflammatory cytokines, suggesting that LL-37 cathelicidin may play a critical role in the inflammatory component of skin. In the LL-37-mediated skin inflammation model in mice, the number of neutrophils and macrophages was significantly increased in the skin together with the expression levels of chemokine (C-X-C motif) ligand (CXCL) 2 and chemokine (C-C motif) ligand (CCL) [71]. In addition, LL-37 and MMP-9 are expressed by neutrophils recruited from tissues in response to inflammation [73].
LL-37 promotes leukocyte chemotaxis and the release of proinflammatory mediators, such as IL-6 and MMP-9, from mast cells [74–78], where the density increases in skin rosacea and is correlated with the duration of disease [79]. In addition, the levels of chymase and tryptase released by mast cells were significantly elevated in the skin of mice injected with the LL-37 peptide and in skin biopsies of rosacea patients [73,80]. The role of mast cells was further confirmed when LL-37 injection in mice knocked out for mast cells did not develop any phenotype. Moreover, mast cell repopulation in these mice restored LL-37-induced skin inflammation and release of the proinflammatory factors IL-6 and MMP-9 [73].
Few of the conducted studies have been performed in the eye, and there is no clear evidence implicating LL-37 in ocular rosacea. LL-37 is naturally present in the conjunctiva, cornea, and Moll glands located between the eyelashes on the eyelid. Its expression increases in response to certain inflammatory processes, including corneal damage, corneal ulcers, or exposure to pathogenic microorganisms [81]. The α- and β-defensins expressed on the ocular surface are capable of inducing chemotaxis of monocytes and neutrophils, stimulating the production of cytokines and the release of histamine by mast cells [45,47], and they have been involved in corneal infections or dry eye [82]. More recently, Go et al. [27] demonstrated increased conjunctival LL-37 gene expression and increased tear levels of β-defensins in patients with ocular rosacea. However, whether LL-37 directly induces ocular rosacea has not been determined.
As described above, mast cells are essential in LL-37-induced skin inflammation, and their number increases in the rosacea skin, contributing to the inflammatory immune mechanism [73,80]. In addition, mast cells participate in fibrosis and vascular deregulation associated with rosacea. The histamine and tryptase released by these immune cells promote vasodilation, angiogenesis, and fibrosis by recruiting fibroblasts and MMPs. The fibroblasts stimulate mast cells and promote the release of MMP-1, which can also act on fibroblasts, facilitating fibrosis [78]. Clinically, patients with fibrosis have a phyma. Other factors are implicated in rosacea fibrosis, such as MMPs, serine proteases, growth factors, cytokines, and chemokines [17].
Mast cells play a role in the rosacea pathogenesis by enhancing vasodilation and angiogenesis via different interaction ways [83]. They can produce various proangiogenic molecules, such as VEGF and fibroblast growth factor (FGF), stimulating the migration and proliferation of vascular endothelial cells. FGF is a well-known proangiogenic molecule that, along with VEGF factor, appears to be pivotal in the regulation of angiogenesis [84]. Mast cells can also stimulate the release of proteinases and heparin, allowing the release of other proangiogenic factors and the recruitment of macrophages, among other cells [83]. In addition, during degranulation, mast cells release large amounts of histamine, which is a powerful vasodilator of the body that leads to inflammation, redness, and edema [85]. Finally, mast cells release chymase, a potent local angiotensin-converting enzyme that produces angiotensin II [86]. Angiotensin regulates vascular constriction and endothelial dysfunction, and angiotensin receptors are expressed not only in skin vessels but also in sebaceous glands and dermal fibroblasts [87]. Mast cell degranulation is activated by neuropeptides and sympathetic innervation contributing to the neurogenic inflammation pathway [88].
T-cell-mediated responses-- Little is known about the adaptive immune system in rosacea. The α- and β-defensins induce chemotaxis of T lymphocytes and stimulate the production of antibodies by B lymphocytes [45,47]. These molecules act at the interface between the innate immune system and the adaptive immune system. Extremely high levels of CD4(+) T cells have been observed around the hair follicles and in the perivascular region in rosacea skin [23], where the CD4(+) T cell response is dominated by T lymphocyte helper (TH)1/TH17 polarized immune cells, accompanied by a significant upregulation of IFN-γ and IL-17 [22,23]. In the mouse model of LL-37 peptide-induced inflammation, high levels of CD4(+) T cells were also found in the dermis [41]. TH17 cell-mediated immune responses are implicated in other dermatological pathologies, such as psoriatic dermatitis, in the recruitment of mast cells increases significantly with an upregulation of IL-17 [89].
B-cell-mediated responses-- B lymphocytes and plasma cells seem to be also involved in the adaptive immune response in rosacea. This is shown by the significant increase in the expression level of a B cell marker, CD20, in skin biopsies [23].
Moura et al. [21] suggested the implication of plasmacytoid dendritic cells (pDCs) in the inflammatory response in rosacea. These cells are present at the site of the lesion on the skin biopsies of patients with rosacea, as they are in psoriasis [90]. The cells stimulate CD4 helper T cells and B lymphocytes following certain viral infections and can secrete large quantities of IFN-α and β [91].
Recently, a new molecule has surfaced in the pathology of rosacea. Koebnerisin (S100A15) is an antimicrobial peptide involved in immune-mediated inflammatory responses in various dermatological pathologies, including psoriasis [92] and rosacea [93]. Regulated by TH1 and TH17 cells, koebnerisin acts as a chemoattractant for leukocytes [94,95]. Skin biopsies of patients with rosacea showed high levels of koebnerisin [93]. In vitro, human keratinocytes cultured with koebnerisin secrete MMP-9 and VEGF, suggesting that it could be proangiogenic [93]. Koebnerisin induced the production of TNF-α, IL-6, IL-8, and IL-1β in keratinocytes and leukocytes [92]. However, its role in ocular rosacea is unknown.
Endoplasmic reticulum (ER) stress protects cellular functions from internal disturbances, such as protein misfolding, and from external disturbances, such as exposure to UVB and microbes. It has been implicated in various skin diseases, such as melanoma and Darier’s disease [96]. In cutaneous rosacea, ER stress has been shown to increase the expression and reactivity of TLR-2 via activating transcription factor 4 (ATF4) signaling in epithelial cells [97]. In addition, it stimulates the production of the antimicrobial peptide LL-37 via the sphingosine-1-phosphate (S1P)-NK-κB/EBPα-dependent pathway [98]. Thus, the ER stress could participate in the inflammation in rosacea via LL-37.
Recently, Li et al. [99] highlighted the implication of a new molecule, decysin 1, coded by the ADAMDEC1 gene, in the pathophysiology of cutaneous rosacea. Decysin 1 is part of the ADAM family (a disintegrin and metalloproteinases), which are proteins linked to matrix metalloproteases and snake venom proteins. ADAMDEC1 has been associated with many inflammatory diseases, such as atherosclerosis and pulmonary sarcoidosis. ADAMDEC1 was strongly expressed in type M1 macrophages (proinflammatory) in skin biopsies of rosacea patients. Its inhibition prevented the polarization of the macrophages M1, and subsequent release of IL-6, iNOS, and TNF-α in the THP-1 cell line and in vivo in a murine model of rosacea induced by LL-37 [99]. Thus, ADAMDEC1 could be a new player in inflammation in the pathology of rosacea by regulating the polarization of M1 macrophages. In the context of the eye, there is no information in the literature linking this molecule to ocular rosacea and ocular surface pathologies.
In Table 1, the major molecular findings involved in the deregulation of the innate and adaptive immune systems and clinical effects are shown. In Figure 3, the possible mechanisms of involvement of the immunity system in the pathophysiology of rosacea is indicated.
The blood and lymphatic vessels are important for maintaining skin homeostasis. Increased skin blood flow, persistent vascular and lymphatic dilation, increased vascular permeability, and vascular hyperresponsiveness are signs of rosacea [100,101]. Cathelicidins and VEGF are involved in vasodilation and angiogenesis [102]. In skin biopsies of rosacea patients, VEGF expression is increased in the epidermis and in infiltrating cells, associated with enhanced expression of platelet/endothelial cell adhesion molecule-1 (CD31), a marker for the endothelium of blood vessels, and D240, a marker for lymphatic vessels [24,103,104]. Elevated levels of VEGF receptors, VEGF-R1 and VEGF-R2, were measured in the vascular endothelium, infiltrating mononuclear cells, and the serum of patients with rosacea [105].
LL-37 exerts proangiogenic effects through the activation of formyl peptide type 1 (FPR1) receptor, epidermal growth factor receptor (EGFR), and downstream signaling in epithelial cells [104]. LL-37 can also increase levels of VEGF in epidermal keratinocytes [36]. The injection of LL-37 into the skin of mice promoted erythema and vascular dilation [61], and LL-37 increased the density of microvessels and the expression of VEGF [41]. An important role of endothelial cells is their ability to express adhesion molecules, such as the vascular cell adhesion molecule-1 (VCAM-1) or the intracellular adhesion molecule-1 (ICAM-1) and selectins [106]. LL-37 has been shown to increase the expression of ICAM-1 on endothelial cells in patients with atherosclerosis [107]. In a recently released study, biopsies from rosacea patients showed high expression of the VCAM-1, ICAM-1, and E-selectin molecules, along with high expression of LL-37 [108].
It has been reported that increased ER stress, accompanied by an increase in LL-37, promotes angiogenesis. ER stress increases the expression of factor VEGF-A in rosacea [24], and ATF4 acts as a transcription factor for VEGF-A [109]. Thus, ER stress, via LL-37 and the control of the regulation of VEGF-A seems to be involved in vascular anomalies of rosacea.
Angiogenesis and inflammation can act as mutual enhancers [110]. VEGF has both an angiogenic and inflammatory regulatory role, and inhibition of vascular activation has been shown to have anti-inflammatory properties [17].
One of the severe complications of ocular rosacea is CNV and subsequent corneal remodeling and opacification. It is defined by the appearance of new vessels, which develop from preexisting vessels and invade the initially avascular cornea due to a disturbance in the balance between proangiogenic and antiangiogenic factors. Abnormal growth of blood vessels and the resulting corneal opacity affect corneal transparency [111]. CNV is associated with the production of TNF-α, MCP-1, IL-6, and proangiogenic factors, such as VEGF and FGF, by corneal endothelial cells, Langerhans cells, macrophages, and inflammatory cells [112]. VEGF deregulates the production of MMPs and stimulates the formation of blood vessels, and the angiogenic cascade is amplified by inflammation [112,113]. In the physiological state, corneal avascularity is maintained by soluble forms of the VEGF receptors, VEGF-R1 and 3, which act as endogenous blockers of the proangiogenic action of VEGF [111]. In contrast, VEGF stimulates corneal angiogenesis mainly by the activation of the membrane isoform VEGF-R2. Numerous studies have shown an upregulation of VEGF in the vascular corneas. Its expression is markedly increased in corneal epithelial cells with inflammation, in corneal endothelial cells, vascular endothelial cells, and in macrophage infiltrates [114]. IL-1β has also been shown to induce CNV [115]. In a model of CNV in rats by implantation of disks impregnated with an angiogenic stimulator (basic FGF or VEGF), the antagonism of IL-1β allowed a significant decrease in angiogenesis in vivo, with a decrease in corneal neovessels confirmed by a decrease in CD31 expression. Anti-angiogenic factors are also expressed in the corneal epithelium, such as thrombospondin-1 (TSP-1) and the pigment epithelium-derived factor (PEDF), which has been identified as a potent antiangiogenic factor contributing to the inhibition of the growth of new corneal vessels [116].
The cytokines IL-6 and IL-17 have been shown to induce CNV and stimulate the production of VEGF. Angiotensin II, a potent inducer of vascular inflammation, has been shown to combine with IL-6 and stimulate the induction of VEGF. Activation of STAT3 by IL-6 can also lead to the production of VEGF in corneal fibroblasts [117]. IL-17 promoted the production of VEGF in cultured fibroblasts, associating this molecule with angiogenesis and rosacea [118]. In addition, as seen in skin rosacea, the levels of IL-18, which is involved in the activation of the inflammasome, are increased. However, its role in the eye remains unclear. It has been shown that, in patients with macular edema because of retinal venous occlusion, IL-18 levels increase significantly after treatment, with high levels of IL-18 being correlated with good visual outcome [119]. An inverse relationship between IL-18 expression and VEGF has been shown. Indeed, in patients with ischemic retinopathy, the suppression of VEGF is accompanied by an increase in the expression of IL-18. In addition, injecting IL-18 intraocularly reduces VEGF-induced leakage and neovascularization. This shows that IL-18 and VEGF suppress the production and effects of the other on the vascular system, suggesting an antiangiogenic role for IL-18. To our knowledge, this relationship has not yet been explored in the case of ocular rosacea.
The expression and cellular distribution of leukocyte adhesion molecules have been studied in ocular rosacea [120,121]. Conjunctival biopsies from patients with ocular rosacea showed expression levels of LFA-1, its ligand ICAM-1, and VCAM-1, which showed perivascular cell distribution, compared with the control group. CD105, which is involved in angiogenesis and vascular remodeling, has shown low levels in the normal and healthy vascular endothelium and increased levels in patients with ocular rosacea with inflammatory activation [28]. Thus, the expression of these molecules allows the recruitment of leukocytes contributing to the immune response, as observed in cutaneous rosacea.
The neuronal control of inflammation and vascular dynamics could be a plausible link for the different signs of cutaneous and ocular rosacea. Patients with skin rosacea are sensitive to triggers, such as cold, heat, UV rays, stress, and many others, which indicate the relevance of the sensory and autonomic nervous systems in the pathogenesis of the disease. Sensory and autonomous nerves are important in controlling immunity and vessel dynamics. Close collocation between sensory nerves and blood vessels has been found in the skin of rosacea patients [122].
Most of the environmental factors described above activate ion channels with TRP, a family of nonselective cation channels permeable to Ca2+ having sensory and signaling functions throughout the body and reactive to thermal, chemical, and mechanical stimuli. The TRP channels are divided into the seven following subfamilies: ankyrin (TRPA), cationic (TRPC), melastatin (TRPM), mucolipin (TRPML), mechanosensory (TRPN), polycystic (TRPP), and vanilloid TRP (TRPV). Different stimuli can activate TRP, including the following: pungent compounds, such as capsaicin (TRPV-1) and mustard oil (TRPA-1 and TRPV-1), heat (TRPV-1), cold (TRPA-1), UVB irradiation (TRPV-4), and cosmetics (TRPA-1) [123]. TRPs, which are located in sensory nerves and other nonneuronal cells, such as mast cells, dendritic cells, and endothelial cells and keratinocytes, are capable of triggering cell secretion events via the influx of cations, including Ca2+, and they are known to participate in nociceptive and neurogenic inflammatory processes. When the TRP channels are activated by external stimuli, such as heat, this leads to the release of vasoactive neuropeptides, such as substance P (SP), the peptide linked to the calcitonin gene (CGRP), the activator polypeptide of l pituitary adenylate cyclase (PACAP), the vasoactive intestinal peptide (VIP), or even bradykinin, associated with centrofacial vasodilation [20].
In rosacea skin, abnormally high expressions of certain TRPs have been found, including TRPV-1, which has proinflammatory properties and is involved in vasoregulation contributing to acute and chronic pain; TRPV-2, which is involved in vasodilation and immunomodulation; and TRPV-3, which is involved in inflammation and fibrosis [25]. Neurovascular deregulation of these receptors could contribute to the onset of flushing seen in rosacea skin. In particular, an increase in the density of nerve fibers, as well as an increase in the expression of TRPV-1 expression has been found in the skin of patients with erythematotelangiectatic rosacea compared with healthy skin [17]. Interestingly, channels TRPV-2 and 4 have been shown to be co-located with mast cells in the skin of rosacea patients [25]. In vivo, in the LL-37 mouse model, increased expression of TRPV-2 and TRPV-4 was shown in mouse skin, as was the colocalization of TRPV-2 with mast cells. In vitro, using primary murine mast cells, increased expression of TRPV-2 and TRPV-4 was observed in response to LL-37, and activation of TRPV-4 induced mast cell degranulation via Ca2+ flux [124]. LL-37 could increase the expression of TRPV-4 via the activation of a protein-coupled receptor, Mas-related gene X2 (MRGX2), leading to the activation of mast cells and their degranulation stimulated by the influx of Ca2+ [125]. This activation of mast cells could also involve the p38 and Erk MAPK signaling pathway. In fact, its inhibition showed a considerable decrease in the degranulation of mast cells induced by LL-37 [126]. Since TLR-2 signaling pathways are involved in neuroinflammation and neuronal damage [127], the association between neurons and immune deregulation could in part be explained by TLR-2.
The TRPC-1, TRPC-4, and TRPA-1 channels have also been shown to be involved in vascular permeability. In one study, Paria et al. [128] showed that TNF-α-induced expression of TRPC-1 led to increased Ca2+ influx and vascular permeability. Mice deficient in TRPC-4 showed reduced endothelial permeability [129]. TRPA-1, another subfamily of TRP channels, has been shown to be regulated in skin rosacea. Like TRPVs, TRPAs are expressed in sensory neurons, and in 50% of cases, coexpressed with TRPV-1 receptors, suggesting mutual control of transduction of stimuli in sensory neurons [130]. These channels are temperature sensitive and have been shown to be activated by spices, such as mustard oil and cinnamon, and thermal stimuli. In addition, they have been shown to mediate vasodilation [131]. In rat neurons, TRPA-1 channels have been shown to be collocated with PAR-2, which, as we have seen, contributes to inflammation and is activated by proteases, such as KLK-5. Therefore, PAR-2 appears to be involved in inflammation, as well as a neuronal process via TRPA-1, which further exacerbates the inflammatory response.
The eye is innervated by three types of nerves—sensory, sympathetic, and parasympathetic nerves. Several publications in the literature have studied the involvement of TRP channels and neurotransmitters in the eye. However, to our knowledge, there are no studies to date that directly link these molecules to ocular rosacea.
The cornea is densely innervated by sensory nerve fibers from the trigeminal nerve, which enters the corneal stroma through the limbus and innervates the corneal epithelium. Corneal innervation contributes to high sensitivity to physical and chemical stimuli [132]. Correct innervation is essential for maintaining the structure and function of the cornea. Different subtypes of TRP channels are expressed in cells and on human corneal sensory nerve endings, including TRPV-1–4, TRPA-1 and TRPM-8 and conjunctival including TRPV-1, 2, and 4 [133]. The degree of TRPV-1 immunoreactivity in the corneal neurons is also higher than that observed in the skin. In humans, TRPV-1 is expressed in all the corneal layers, in the basal layer of the conjunctiva, while TRPA-1 is only expressed in the corneal endothelium [134,135]. The TRPV-1 and TRPA-1 subtypes have been shown to be involved in the healing of corneal wounds by stimulating cell proliferation and migration, in transparency, in fibrosis, neovascularization, and inflammation with the release of proinflammatory cytokines including IL-6 and IL-8 via the p38 and Erk MAPK signaling pathway and the activation of NF-κB [136,137]. In a mouse model of CNV by chemical burn, the activation of TRPV-1 in all the corneal layers induced fibrosis, deregulated inflammation, neovascularization, opacification, and release of corneal resident cytokines leading to the activation of immune cells [138]. Corneal transparency was restored in mice deficient in TRPV-1, accompanied by a decrease in the release of proinflammatory cytokines. Improved healing has also been observed with repeated intraperitoneal injections of TRPV-1 antagonists [138]. In addition, TRPV-1 has been shown to be associated with transforming growth factor-beta 1 (TGF-β1) and to cause fibrosis [139]. A decrease in inflammation and fibrosis has also been shown in mice deficient for TRPA-1 [140]. In a recent study, the involvement of TRPA-1 in wound healing and neovascularization was studied using a model for the healing of corneal lesions in mice leading to CNV [141]. Removal of TRPA-1 significantly reduced expression of CD31, reduced infiltration of stromal macrophages, and expression levels of VEGF-A and TGF-β1 by 70%. Targeting the activation of TRPA-1 may be a therapeutic option to improve visual acuity by improving corneal transparency.
Studies have shown that TRPM-8 channels, which are sensitive to cold and expressed in the eyelid and cornea, are involved in neuropathic pain and dry eyes [142]. Mice deficient in TRPM-8 showed a reduction in basal secretion of tears, indicating a role for TRPM-8 in controlling basal lacrimal flow [143]. More recently, TRPV-1 and TRPA-1 channels have also been implicated in dry eye. In a tear-deficient dry eye model, stimulation with TRPA-1 agonist, mustard oil (agonist of TRPA-1), on the eyes showed a decrease in tear secretion by 50% and significantly increased spontaneous blinking [144].
The TRPV receptors and neuropeptides produced are linked to the inflammatory immune mechanisms of rosacea through neurogenic inflammation, in which the sensory nerves contribute to inflammation. Elevated levels of neuropeptides, such as PACAP, SP, VIP, and CGRP, have also been found in the skin of rosacea patients, and they tend to increase the expression of TRPV channels [122]. Neuropeptides/neurotransmitters released from sympathetic and sensory nerve endings regulate the main immune functions, such as antigen presentation, antibody production, T cell activity, lymphocyte activity, and cytokine secretion (neuroinflammation). They can recruit and activate target immune cells, such as neutrophils, macrophages, and mast cells, which express the α- and β-adrenergic receptors, by the upregulation of vascular adhesion molecules [145-148]. The modulation of α-adrenergic receptors and the inhibition of β-adrenergic ones has been shown to be useful in some patients [122]. In turn, activated macrophages secrete proinflammatory factors, such as MMPs, IL-1, TNF-α, and IL-12, and activated neutrophils secrete reactive oxygen species (ROS) and proteases. Mast cells, stimulated by neuropeptides, cause the release of histamine, which is involved in vasodilation and inflammation; tryptase, a fibroblast chemoattracting agent, and MMPs [122,149,150]. The activation of fibroblasts and the production of MMPs can subsequently lead to cutaneous fibrosis observed in rosacea at an advanced stage.
SP has been shown to be involved in the vascular permeability and plasma extravasation seen in rosacea skin, while the other molecules are associated with vasodilation. The release of SP increases the expression of ICAM and VCAM in vascular endothelial cells and the release of VEGF from mast cells, promoting the proliferation and vascularization of endothelial cells [88]. The neuropeptide CGRP is a powerful vasodilator that contributes to neurogenic vasodilation and the recruitment of leukocytes. SP and CGRP have been shown to promote the polarization of Langerhans cells, which are epidermal dendritic cells involved in the presentation of the antigen, toward TH2-type immunity [151]. The neuropeptide PACAP also appears to be important in pathogenesis. The injection of PACAP into the skin of mice has been shown to upregulate the expression of proteases MMP-1 and MMP-9, as well as the expression of proinflammatory cytokines, such as TNF-α and CXCL2 [73,152]. The increased release of MMP-9 could further lead to inflammation via the LL-37 pathway because MMP-9 promotes the cleavage of cathelicidin into the LL-37 peptide [61]. PACAP can also stimulate the release of nitric oxide (NO) from endothelial cells, leading to vasodilation [153]. These observations suggest the involvement of neurogenic inflammation in the pathophysiological mechanism of cutaneous rosacea, although it is not yet clear whether neural activation precedes or follows the inflammatory infiltrate.
In the eye, the neurotransmitters SP and CGRP were detected in these corneal fibers. In addition to being known in neuroinflammatory processes and modulating the processing of the nociceptive signal, SP is involved in the healing of corneal wounds. It has been shown in mice that approximately 59% of the total epithelial innervation is occupied by nerves expressing SP [154]. In addition, co-expression of TRPV-1 with CGRP and with SP in the corneal neurons has been demonstrated [155]. Thus, TRPV-1 could increase the release of SP and CGRP in the cornea, as in the skin. When released from the corneal nerves, SP and CGRP contribute to the development of a local neurogenic inflammatory response [156].
In Table 2, the major molecular findings involved in the deregulation of both the vascular and neurovascular systems and clinical effects are shown. In Figure 4, the involvement of both neuronal and neurovascular systems in the pathophysiology of rosacea is indicated.
The sebaceous glands-- The surface of the skin is covered by an emulsion of water and grease, forming a hydrolipidic film constituting a protective barrier against microorganisms. The sebaceous glands are intradermal glands present all over the body that secrete sebum, a mixture of lipids and cellular debris, which is important to prevent drying of the skin and which enters the composition of the hydrolipidic film of the skin. Dysfunction of the sebaceous glands has been evidenced in various dermatological pathologies, such as acne vulgaris, atopic dermatitis, and psoriasis [157].
The link between the sebaceous glands and rosacea emerged when treatment with oral isotretinoin (retinoids), which inhibits sebum secretion by the sebaceous glands and was prescribed for acne, unexpectedly reduced erythema and papulopustules in patients with cutaneous rosacea [158]. The lipid analysis of skin hydrolipid film showed that rosacea is associated with a decrease in long-chain saturated fatty acids [159], resulting in reduced skin hydration, although the amounts and rates of sebum secretion are unchanged and do not correlate with the disease severity [157,160]. Alteration of the lipid film quality and the resulting skin dryness favor rosacea. Indeed, in 135 rosacea patients, the erythematotelangiectatic rosacea subtype was more common in dry skin than it was in seborrheic skin [161]. Sebocytes contribute to inflammatory response in rosacea, releasing many proinflammatory factors and adipokines, such as IL-6 [162]. When exposed to danger signals, human sebocytes rapidly acquire a competent immune status [163]. Recent data have shown that skin treated with α-bungarotoxin, an acetylcholine receptor antagonist, decreases sebum secretion and size, suggesting that autonomous innervation regulates the function of the sebaceous glands [164].
Several studies have shown a dysfunction of the sebaceous glands associated with a permeability barrier alteration in the skin of patients with rosacea. In a recent study, Medgyesi et al., have shown that all major components of the skin barrier are altered in papulopustular rosacea, including the altered expression of cornified envelope components, tight junction molecules, barriers alarmins, and AMPs [165]. The barrier disruption may contribute to disease pathophysiology.
The meibomian glands-- The meibomian glands are sebaceous glands located in the epidermis of the lower and upper eyelids, which secrete meibum, a source of tear lipids. They play an essential role in the homeostasis of the ocular surface and in the stability of the tear film, which is the second line of defense of the ocular surface after the eyelids. Any meibomian gland dysfunction leads to poor lubrication of the ocular surface, which manifests by redness, swelling of the edge of the eyelids, and palpebral conjunctivitis around the orifices of the meibomian glands. The term “meibomian gland dysfunction” (MGD) was introduced in 1980 by Korb and Henriquez [166] to describe the obstruction in the meibomian gland by hyperkeratinization of the glandular and epithelium, accompanied by a change in the viscosity of the meibum leading to meibomitis. MGD can be secondary to medication intake such as antidepressants or antihistamines, to pollution, certain dermatological diseases such as rosacea, and infection with a microorganism, which is an important element in the development of MGD. The meibomitis represents a facet of the general dysfunction of the sebaceous glands in association with dermatological disorders of which cutaneous rosacea [167].
One of the main eye signs of ocular rosacea is MGD, as observed in several previous studies [13,26]. MGD has been reported in 50% to 93% of patients with ocular rosacea. MGD is the most common cause of dry eye, which is one of the symptoms of ocular rosacea [168]. Instability of the tear film damages the ocular surface epithelium, leading to the production of proinflammatory cytokines, which aggravate ocular surface inflammation and worsen the MGD [169]. The proinflammatory factors secondary to MGD cause inflammatory signs in eyelid edges [170].
A gene expression study was conducted on meibomian glands isolated from the eyelids of patients with MGD. Nearly 400 genes were differentially regulated, such as genes coding for small proline-rich proteins (SPRRs), calcium binding proteins S100 (S100A7, A8, and A9), or genes coding for keratins [171]. The SPRR proteins and A8 and A9 proteins have been shown to be involved in the development of the epidermis and keratinization [172,173]. Thus, they could be involved in the hyperkeratinization observed in patients with MGD. In addition, the proteins S100A8 and A9 are also involved in inflammatory processes, promoting the recruitment of leukocytes to the site of inflammation and the release of proinflammatory factors. Furthermore, these proteins form a heterodimer called calprotectin, known to be a TLR-4 agonist, which is overexpressed in patients with ocular rosacea [174]. Thus, these molecules could be partly responsible for the ocular inflammation observed in the eyes and the eyelid edges of patients with ocular rosacea.
Patients with ocular rosacea have been shown to have decreased tear production and a low clearance rate [13]. Barton et al. and Afonso et al. [53,54] have shown that, the lower the tear clearance rate in these patients, the higher the concentrations of IL-1α and MMP-9.
The meibomian glands present nervous regulation through their rich sensory, sympathetic, and parasympathetic innervation [175,176]. These nerve fibers express neurotransmitters, such as CGRP, SP, or VIP, released in the vicinity of the glands, which act on glandular receptors [177,178]. These compounds are known to stimulate lacrimal gland secretion [179] and could regulate meibomian gland secretion. However, this remains to be demonstrated.
Genetic predisposition-- Rosacea patients are four times likelier to have a family member with rosacea [180]. Homozygous twins have clinical rosacea scores, as defined by the National Rosacea Society (NRS), that is higher than those observed for heterozygous twins; this demonstrates a contribution of genetic determinant in the disease [15].
A genome-wide association study (GWAS) showed that rosacea was associated with three alleles of human leukocyte antigen (HLA) class II, molecules that present antigens to immune cells [181]. Moreover, a single-nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) in the region of the HLA, the rs763035 polymorphism located between the Human Leukocyte Antigen – DR isotype (HLA-DRA) genes, an allele of the major histocompatibility complex of class I, and butyrophilin-like protein 2 (BTLN2)—which is also involved in the immune system in the activation of T lymphocytes [182]—have been associated with rosacea [181].
A null mutation polymorphism has been found in the gene that codes for glutathione S-transferase (GST), which is involved in cellular defense against oxidative stress [183]. The null genotypes GST mu 1 (GSTM1) and GST theta 1 (GSTT1) have been shown to be associated with a higher risk of developing the disease. The increase in ROS or the decrease in antioxidant potential, two characteristics observed in patients with rosacea, could be linked to the polymorphism of the GST gene.
SNP rs3733631, located in the tachykinin 3 receptor gene (TARC-3)—which comprises the endogenous ligand neurokinin B—was found in patients with rosacea, with a higher frequency than in the control group [184]. Tachykinins are a family of neuropeptides including substance P, neurokinin A, and neurokinin B, which bind to the TARC-1, TARC-2, and TARC-3 receptors, respectively. Neurons in the hypothalamus that express neurokinin B have been shown to promote skin vasodilation and estrogenic modulation of body temperature, leading to hot flashes in postmenopausal women, a characteristic common to rosacea [185]. The gene that codes for the TLR-2 receptor located on chromosome 4q32 has been shown to be adjacent to TARC-3 located at 4q25. Polymorphism in the TARC-3 receptor may contribute to the increased expression of TLR-2 seen in rosacea. This hypothesis remains to be confirmed.
The rs11168271 (ApaI), rs731336 (TaqI), and rs11568820 (Cdx2) polymorphisms in the vitamin D receptor (VDR) have been associated with rosacea. The authors demonstrated that polymorphisms of heterozygous and mutant ApaI alleles increased the risk of rosacea, while polymorphisms of mutant TaqI alleles decreased the risk of rosacea. Likewise, the heterozygous Cdx2 alleles increased the risk of rosacea, while the wild forms of the ApaI and mutant TaqI alleles reduced the risk. This demonstrates the involvement of vitamin D signaling in the disease [186,187].
Recently, Hayran et al. [105] investigated the association between polymorphisms in the gene that codes for the proangiogenic factor VEGF and rosacea. The study showed high expression of VEGF in the facial skin biopsies of patients with rosacea compared to the healthy group. Interestingly, they observed that the heterozygous and homozygous +405C/G polymorphism of the gene encoding VEGF increased the risk of rosacea by 1.7 times. A positive correlation between the severity of clinical signs and the +405C/G polymorphism has been found in patients with erythematotelangiectatic rosacea [105]. Although genetic predispositions favor the occurrence and severity of the disease, it seems to be one of the factors in a multifactorial and complex disease.
Corticosteroids-- Corticosteroids are hormones secreted by the cortex of the adrenal glands. In this part of the gland, a distinction is made between mineralocorticoids (aldosterone) in the glomerular zone, glucocorticoids (GCs) in the fasciculate zone, and androgens in the reticulate zone.
Because of their anti-inflammatory and immunosuppressive properties, GCs are used in the treatment of many inflammatory ocular and skin conditions. However, GCs delay wound healing [188,189], and chronic treatment of dermatological diseases with steroids results in a clinical form similar to rosacea, called rosacea-like dermatitis induced by steroids or perioral dermatitis [190-192]. This includes erythema, pustules, and papules like those seen in rosacea skin. Thus, GCs could contribute to disease pathogenic mechanisms.
The skin is the target organ of systemic GCs. The GC receptor (GR) has been shown to be involved in the differentiation of keratinocytes and in the formation of the skin barrier. In addition, keratinocytes express several enzymes that are necessary in the GCs production pathway, such as cytochrome P450 11A1 (CYP11A1), cytochrome P450 17A1 (CYP17A1), cytochrome P450 21 (CYP21), or even the metastatic lymph node 64 (MLN64) protein [193]. The skin cells express human 11β-hydroxysteroid dehydrogenase type 1 (11β-HSD1) and 11β-hydroxysteroid dehydrogenase type 2 (11β-HSD2), which transform cortisone into cortisol and vice versa, allowing activation and inactivation of GCs in the skin. In rosacea skin, the expression levels of CYP11A1, CYP21A2, and 11β-HSD1, as well as the expression of GR, increase significantly, suggesting de novo synthesis of GCs and their receptors simultaneously [194,195]. The sebaceous glands have been demonstrated to be a key target of GCs, acting as enzyme factories to produce GCs. The expression of CYP11A1 was increased in the sebaceous glands and in the epidermis of patients [194].
Surprisingly, GCs can enhance the expression of TLR-2 in human keratinocytes in culture through activation of the p38 MAPK signaling pathway, which is abolished by the GR antagonist RU 486 [196]. GCs induce TLR-2, which induces the recruitment of MyD88, a TLR-2 adaptor molecule [197]. However, a direct link between the expression of TLR-2 by GCs and the increase in inflammatory responses mediated by TLR-2 has not yet been demonstrated. Thus, GCs could paradoxically strengthen immunity by upregulating TLR-2. Different studies have shown that UV radiation, one of the aggravating factors of rosacea, upregulates 11β-HSD1 and downwardly adjusts 11β-HSD2, stimulating the production of GCs [198-200].
Although GCs represses the NF-κB pathway and the transcription of anti-inflammatory genes [201], hyperactivation of the mineralocorticoid receptor, which binds GCs and aldosterone with similar affinity, caused epidermal hyperplasia, impaired differentiation, and increased dermal infiltrates, correlating with increased NF-κB signaling and upregulation of TNF-α and IL-6 cytokines, showing that doses of GCs prone to saturate both receptors could contribute to GC-induced skin side effects [202,203]. GC-induced skin atrophy was also shown to result from inappropriate activation of the mineralocorticoid receptor, and it was prevented by mineralocorticoid receptor antagonism [204].
Synthetic GCs are widely used to treat several eye conditions. However, some patients receiving chronic treatment are likely to develop increased intraocular pressure, cataracts leading to vision loss, or sensitivity to infections [205]. In the cornea, GCs are known to inhibit the growth of vessels and decrease inflammation, but as in the skin, they are also associated with delayed healing of corneal wounds [206] through activation of the mineralocorticoid pathway [207-209].
The relationship between immunity and NF-κB and GCs in ocular rosacea has not yet been studied. It would be interesting to know whether there is a link between inflammatory immunity and corticosteroids in ocular rosacea. In Table 3, the major molecular findings of the aggravation of the disease by endogenous factors and clinical effects are shown.
Demodex-- Demodex mites are other factors that may be related to the initiation or worsening of ocular and skin rosacea. Demodex folliculorum (D. folliculorum) and D. brevis are the two species described that can colonize human skin. D. folliculorum is found in hair follicles, while D. brevis is found mainly in the sebaceous and meibomian glands. Demodex mites colonize all areas of human skin, but a larger number is found in the facial skin [210]. These mites generally do not cause dermatological problems unless they reach a large number (≥5 mites/cm2) or enter the derma [211-213]. The association between Demodex and rosacea is strong, although the mechanisms remain unknown and controversial [214]. The mite population is five to seven times higher on skin biopsies of rosacea patients, and it correlates with the disease severity, being mostly found in papulopustular and infiltrating forms of the disease [39,211,212,215-219]. Quality and quantity of sebum are considered responsible for increased mite infestation [159,213,220,221], in that mite infestation is more frequent in drier or seborrheic skin [31] compared with normal skin [210]. Kubanov et al. [222] showed that Demodex colonization increases the duration of the disease (more than 5 years) and the likelihood of recurrence (from one to three relapses in 40% of patients), as well as that severe forms of rosacea are mostly associated with D. folliculorum.
Increased numbers of mites have been implicated in skin inflammation and the further aggravation of rosacea [39,215,223]. Indeed, Lacey et al. [214] have shown that live Demodex mites cocultivated with human sebocytes can modulate the immune response in vitro. In small numbers, mites tend to suppress the production of cytokines, as well as regulating downward expression of TLR-2, NF-κB, and CD180, a gene that encodes for a homologous TLR-4 receptor [37]. In greater numbers, they induce the release of proinflammatory factors, such as IL-8, and activate the TLR-2 pathway. The polysaccharide chitin contained in the mite exoskeleton is known to activate TLR-2 and facilitate the activation of the NLRP3 inflammasome [224]. Another pathogenic mechanism could be related to the mechanical blockade of hair follicles and sebaceous glands, causing disturbance of the skin barrier and tissue damage. Histologically, this phenomenon is supported by the presence of inflammatory infiltrations around enlarged hair follicles containing demodex mites in rosacea skin [225].
The inflammatory reaction could be aggravated by resident bacteria, such as Bacillus oleronius, released by dying mites, leading to the chemotaxis of more immune cells, such as neutrophils [226,227]. The secreted proinflammatory factors will attract more immune cells into the tissues, aggravating the inflammation reaction. In addition, activated neutrophils are known to release LL-37 and MMP-9, causing even more tissue damage [16]. More recently, Schaller et al. [228] showed that a dual anti-inflammatory and antiparasitic effect of ivermectin allows a significant reduction in Demodex mites and inflammatory genes.
In ophthalmology, Demodex is also known to play a role in chronic blepharitis, conjunctiva inflammation, corneal lesions, and dysfunction of the meibomian glands, all characteristics of ocular rosacea [30,229]. D. folliculorum is located in the follicles of eyelashes and causes anterior blepharitis associated with eyelash disorders. D. brevis is found in the sebaceous glands of the eyelashes and meibomian glands and is associated with posterior blepharitis with MGD and keratoconjunctivitis [230]. These phenomena can spread to the conjunctiva and cornea, causing keratitis and CNV in more severe cases, thereby compromising vision [231]. However, the spread of inflammation to the conjunctiva and cornea depends not only on the severity of the host’s inflammatory response but also on the distance from the Demodex infestation site. It has been shown that in patients with ocular rosacea with corneal complications, the number of D. brevis mites is significantly increased compared with patients who do not have corneal lesions. This observation is consistent with the fact that D. brevis is mainly found in the meibomian glands and can easily reach the conjunctiva and corneal tissues [213,232].
Eradication of Demodex is associated with a reduction in the tear cytokines IL-1β and IL-17, demonstrating the proinflammatory effect of the mites [233-235]. Bacillus oleronius may also be involved in the inflammatory eye process by enhancing the expression of inflammatory mediators MMP-3 and MMP-9 by corneal epithelial cells [236]. The reduction in the density of Demodex mites observed after treatment with topical ivermectin to 1%, an antihelminthic, was accompanied by a marked improvement in clinical skin and eye signs. In addition, a significant decrease in LL-37, IL-8, and TLR-2 was observed [237].
A better understanding of the mechanisms of action of these mites is needed to understand what triggers the transition from an initial immunosuppression to an immunostimulation state after Demodex colonization [238]. Yet, the presence of many mites may simply be an aggravating factor rather than a possible cause.
UV and ROS-- UV irradiation is a well-known trigger factor for cutaneous rosacea. Exposure to UV rays leads to changes in the extracellular matrix of the dermis and an inflammatory reaction with a predominance of neutrophils, an important source of ROS generated by both UVA and UVB rays. These free radicals can activate MMPs, which will cause breaks in dermal collagen, as well as inducing vascular damage and alterations in perivascular collagen [239].
Some studies have linked ROS to the etiology of cutaneous rosacea. In one study, Bakar et al. [240] showed that ROS levels were much higher in skin biopsies of rosacea patients compared with healthy controls. Oztas et al. [239] and Falay Gur et al. [220] studied the role of free radicals in the etiology of rosacea. They found that, in patients with mild rosacea, the antioxidant activity was higher to protect the skin, while in patients with severe rosacea, the activity of superoxide dismutase was low and levels of malondialdehyde high, demonstrating an antioxidant system defect in these patients. Tisma et al. [241] showed an increase in the ferritin content in the skin of rosacea patients following UV irradiation, as well as an increase in the resulting oxidative damage. It is known that iron overload can amplify the harmful effects of ROS, acting as a catalyst for reactions between ROS regulation and biomolecules. Excess iron has been shown in various dermatological pathologies, such as psoriasis or atopic eczema. More recently, in another study, Erdogan et al. [242] showed high oxidative stress in these patients, as well as an increased antioxidant status, probably as a compensatory mechanism. The level of advanced oxidation protein products (AOPPs), which reflect the oxidation of proteins derived from neutrophils and macrophages, was also increased. However, more studies are needed to determine whether the imbalance between the oxidant and antioxidant systems in the pathology of rosacea is a cause or consequence of this.
UV radiation is also associated with innate immunity in cutaneous rosacea with the production of cytokines and chemokines, such as IL-1β, IL-6, TNF-α, and IL-8, in a temporal and dose-dependent manner [243,244]. As mentioned above, to be active, IL-1β requires cleavage by caspase-1, a component of the NLRP3 inflammasome. Feldmeyer et al. [245] showed that keratinocytes exposed to UVB have the capacity to secrete IL-1β via the activation of the inflammasome, which shows that these cells can induce an inflammatory response following UVB irradiation. The release of ROS by cells, such as neutrophils, can also result in inflammation of the skin accompanied by activation of the inflammasome, upregulation of the NF-κB factor, release of proinflammatory cytokines, and other inflammatory mediators produced by keratinocytes and fibroblasts, leading to an exacerbation of inflammation [246].
UV-induced eye damage has been demonstrated in various human studies. The cornea is the most affected structure of the eye by UVB radiation, with an absorption of around 90% [132]. UV irradiation induces an inflammatory response, such as swelling of the stroma, and it is accompanied by significant leukocyte infiltration [247]. As in the case of the skin, at the ocular level, UVB can induce the production of ROS and proinflammatory cytokines [248]. UVB irradiation has been shown to increase the secretion levels of IL-6 and IL-8 by human corneal and conjunctival epithelial cells in vitro [249]. In one study, Chen et al. [250] showed that UVB irradiation in animals induces visible corneal inflammation and severe epithelialized exfoliation. High levels of TNF-α expression were observed in these animals compared to the control group. In addition, the corneal stroma has been strongly infiltrated by leukocytes. Korhonen et al. [251] have shown that exposure to UVB of human corneal epithelial cells (HCEs) in vitro induced an increase in the activity of NLRP3, as well as that of caspase-1, accompanied by an increase in the secretion of IL-1β. This shows that the inflammatory mechanism mediated by the activity of the inflammasome after exposure to UVB radiation also seems to be present in the eye. However, to date, no study has directly linked the effects of UV light and the immune inflammation mechanism in a specific case of ocular rosacea.
UV and LL-37-- There seems to be a link between LL-37 and UVB in the pathophysiology of rosacea. Cutaneous rosacea patients exhibit an aggravated inflammatory response and production of ROS as a function of dose and time when they are exposed to UV radiation [252]. UVB-exposed keratinocytes cultured in the presence of LL-37 secrete higher levels of IL-1β and IL-18 than those that have not been cultured in the presence of the proinflammatory peptide, suggesting that the mechanism by which LL-37 causes the production of these cytokines could involve the activity of the inflammasome [253]. In another recent in vitro study, using HaCaT cells (transformed aneuploid immortal keratinocyte cell line from adult human skin) exposed to LL-37 and irradiated with UVB, Suhng et al. [254] showed a significant increase in the expression of IL-33, a member of the IL-1 family, compared with the LL-37 group alone or UVB alone. The levels of expression of other inflammatory cytokines, such as IL-1α and β, TNF-α, and IFN-γ, also increased. In particular, the expression of IL-1β was the most upregulated one. Therefore, the increased production of these proinflammatory cytokines in the presence of LL-37 may contribute to the susceptibility of rosacea patients to UV radiation.
Activation of LL-37 following UVB irradiation may partly result from ER stress induced by UV irradiation in the human epidermis [255], which may explain the increase in LL-37 levels in skin exposed to UVB. In one study, human skin fibroblasts (Hs68 cells) and mice exposed to UVB showed an increase in markers of ER stress proteins, such as CCAAT-enhancer-binding protein homologous protein (CHOP) and ATF4, in a dose-dependent manner. This effect was significantly reduced after treatment with trigonelline, a naturally occurring alkaloidal agent [256]. The synthesis of 1,25-dihydroxyvitamin D3 [1,25(OH)2D3] caused by UV radiation also induces the expression of cathelicidins in keratinocytes. Wang et al. [257] identified an element of response to vitamin D in the cathelicidin promoter. Serological levels of the active form of vitamin D3 have been shown to be higher in patients with rosacea [258]. In addition, it has been shown that 1,25(OH)2D3 can induce an increase in the expression of TLR-2 and KLK-5 [259]. In this sense, vitamin D seems to play a role in the immune system and in the proinflammatory cascades of rosacea by controlling the expression of certain molecules.
UV and vascular and neuronal systems-- UVB radiation has been linked to angiogenesis by inducing epidermal thickening, dilatation, and hyperpermeability of blood vessels, leading to edema and erythema [260]. UVB has been shown to be able to modulate the angiogenic response by upregulating VEGF, FGF, and IL-8 and by downregulating TSP-1, an anti-angiogenic factor [261]. This is confirmed in skin biopsies of patients with rosacea, in which an inflammatory infiltrate is histologically present at the perivascular level [253]. Hirakawa et al. [262] showed that mice that overexpress VEGF-A are more sensitive to UVB irradiation. Conversely, blocking VEGF-A can reduce skin inflammation and vascular dilation after exposure to UVB. For mice that overexpress TSP-1 in epidermal keratinocytes, the damage induced by UVB is significantly reduced [263]. While the VEGF-A form is increased in the skin of mice after UVB irradiation, the VEGF-C form appears to be downregulated. In addition, inhibition of the VEGF-R3 receptor appears to worsen the phenotype induced by UVB exposure. Conversely, its activation attenuates clinical signs [264]. In addition, the release of IL-1β also contributes to the proangiogenic environment by modulating the activity of endothelial cells [265]. Overall, the inhibition of these pathways could be of interest in preventing photodamage in the pathophysiology of rosacea.
In addition, UVB radiation has been shown to affect the skin and cause sunburn by activating the TRPV-4 channels [266], related to the activity of LL-37, as seen before. After exposure to UVB, mice depleted for the Trpv-4 gene in keratinocytes showed much less sensitivity to thermal and mechanical stimuli, with a reduction in epidermal lesions demonstrating an important role for TRPV-4 in the damage to skin tissues induced by UVB. In addition, an increase in the expression of adhesion molecules like VCAM-1, ICAM-I, and E-selectin have been observed in vitro in human dermal microvascular endothelial cells (HDMECs) in cultures exposed to UVB. Their expression was even stronger than the exposure time and the dose of LL-37 [108]. Together, these observations may partially explain why exposure to UV rays promotes vascular inflammation in rosacea, which could go through LL-37 activity.
Chen et al. [250] have shown that eye irradiation with UVB in animals induces an increase in expression levels of VEGF compared with animals in the control group. Ocular exposure to UVB radiation leads to a significant reduction in innervation in corneal products and alters the density and morphology of sensory nerves, leading to nerve damage and disorganization of the corneal epithelium [132].
Previous studies have shown that neural activation leads to increased levels of the p38 MAPK signaling pathway, which is involved in cellular responses following inflammatory stimuli [267]. In a mouse model near UVB-induced photokeratitis, high levels of p38 and TRPV-1 were found in neurons and in neighboring satellite glial cells, which are known to release inflammatory and immune factors in response to inflammation and nerve damage. In Table 4, the major molecular findings of the aggravation of the disease by exogenous factors and clinical effects.
In vivo models of rosacea-- Animal models have improved our understanding of the pathophysiology of various human diseases. These models, which mimic both diseases and conditions of the human skin and eye, are used to predict the effectiveness of a drug. Currently, there are few animal models mimicking cutaneous and ocular rosacea, which are mainly based on the development of clinical features observed in humans.
Inflammatory skin model induced by the injection of LL-37-- Many studies have shown the central role of the antimicrobial peptide LL-37 in inflammatory and neurovascular processes at the cutaneous and ocular levels in patients with rosacea [61,62]. A model of inflammation induced by the injection of LL-37 into the skin of rodents has been developed, making it possible to best mimic the clinical characteristics and to study the inflammatory and neurological immune mechanisms of the disease [41]. It is an experimental animal model used systematically to study the pathophysiology of cutaneous rosacea. LL-37 injections into the skin of rodents were induced twice a day for 2 days. Animals sensitized to LL-37 exhibit scratching behaviors with the development of characteristics common to those observed in humans, namely, redness, erythema, and skin inflammation [41,61]. The clinical manifestation showed an infiltration of leukocytes at the site of the skin lesion, such as mast cells, neutrophils, macrophages, and CD4+ T lymphocytes, as well as an increased increase in inflammatory mediators, such as IL-1β, TNF-α, and IL-6. The increase in expression levels of the proangiogenic factor VEGF and the TRP involved in the detection of environmental stimuli (heat, cold, etc.) to which rosacea patients seem to be sensitive shows that this model of cutaneous rosacea induced by LL-37 is also relevant for studying the vascular and neurovascular systems [41,124,125,254].
The expression of LL-37 is also increased in patients with ocular rosacea [27]. The development of an ocular model by injection of LL-37 could be interesting to better understand its implications on the ocular level and the associated molecular mechanisms.
Skin and eye inflammation model induced by UVB light-- UVB irradiation in murine models is often used to assess compounds tested on skin photoaging, photo damage, and skin inflammation accompanied by cytokine release and leukocyte infiltration [268,269]. The acute response to exposure to UVB radiation shares several characteristics common to those observed in humans, namely erythema and skin inflammation [16,262,270]. The mechanisms underlying the development of erythema in animals have not been approved as exactly mimicking those seen in humans with erythema associated with rosacea. However, this model makes it possible to study and assess different molecular targets for their ability to develop inflammation and vasoconstriction of blood vessels [271] present in rosacea patients in vivo.
At the ocular level, UVB radiation induces a corneal inflammatory response accompanied by the production of ROS and proinflammatory cytokines [248,250]. A model of photokeratitis by exposure of the eyes to UVB rays has been developed in rodents. This model causes corneal haze, inflammation, and fibrosis, leading to a decrease in visual acuity clinical features observed in patients with ocular rosacea [132,250]. This model does not directly mimic ocular rosacea, but it allows a better understanding of the molecular mechanisms induced by UVB irradiation, which could also be an aggravating factor of the disease.
In vitro models for rosacea-- In the absence of relevant in vivo models, the development of in vitro models can prove to be an effective solution for a better understanding of molecular mechanisms. At both the skin and eye level, the use of organotypic skin and eye equivalents can be well-designed substitutes that mimic the skin and human eye. They are used as an alternative to animal models for drug permeability and toxicity tests.
NHEKs and HaCaTs-- In vitro skin rosacea models further include the culture of normal human epidermal keratinocytes (NHEKs) and the immortalized cell line (HaCaT) of spontaneously transformed human keratinocytes from adult human skin. Epidermal keratinocytes in culture have a variety of applications in research on skin diseases and wound healing; they are also used for efficacy and toxicity testing of molecules.
In the study of the pathophysiology of cutaneous rosacea in vitro, these two models are the most used models to study inflammation during exposure to various factors, including the peptide LL-37 and UVB, which are two important players involved in the disease. When stimulated, these cells can express and release several inflammatory mediators, such as TNF-α and IL-1β, suggesting that these models of epidermal keratinocytes in culture are good models for studying inflammatory responses in vitro and evaluating the action of therapeutic molecules [254,261]. However, they do not explain the complete perplexity of the formation of skin lesions.
The cells at the ocular surface of the corneal and conjunctiva are the cells most frequently exposed to external stimuli leading to the process of inflammation, corneal damage, and cell death. These cells constitute a component of the mucosal immune system and participate in defense mechanisms, notably by initiating an inflammatory response via the release of proinflammatory mediators [272]. They can respond to various stimuli, which is why these cells are interesting cell models. These are the two most widely used models for indirectly studying the pathophysiological molecular mechanisms of ocular rosacea, including the inflammatory mechanisms after exposure to UVB [251]. Corneal epithelial cells are also a good model for studying the interaction of pathogens with the ocular surface [273].
Despite major advances in understanding the pathophysiology of cutaneous and ocular rosacea, the exact mechanisms are still poorly understood. Current hypotheses (Figure 5) focus on the dysfunction of the immune, vascular, and neurovascular systems, which seem to be at the heart of pathogenesis, triggered by microbial or physical stimuli. Since meibomian glands, vessels, and immune cells, such as mast cells, are controlled by autonomous system innervation, it could be hypothesized that the manifestations of ocular rosacea could result from peripheral innervation deregulation, favored by hormonal, infectious, and physical factors. Since neurogenic inflammation is reaching a growing importance in the understanding of migraine [274] and skin inflammation [275], the molecular components of its deregulation in ocular rosacea should be analyzed. This analysis could help develop new study models for ocular rosacea.